Bengal Muslims to Shun Beef This Eid, But...

追加: 2026-05-25

[00:00:00]Kushal accepted everything in West Bengal, that is fine.

[00:00:02]We are saying that this export of meat outside is not right, that animal should be a breed animal, it should be banned for everyone, the sacrifice will be done as told, we will not sacrifice the calf of a cow, otherwise do you feel bad about it or we do not feel bad about it, eating meat means we want meat, we will not allow sacrifice, okay, but it should not be exported, it is being sold all over the world and here you people are asking where is this from?

[00:00:34]You all are Hindus. The goats you sell here are mostly sold by Hindus.

[00:00:39]All Hindu people 70000 75000 400 500 As the goat so shall you be.

[00:00:44]How much did this goat in front sell for?

[00:00:46]25000 What was in it? We used to have five to six shares in the cow and now we have only one share in this. Earlier, five to six people used to sacrifice on one cow and now only one person is sacrificing on one goat.

[00:00:57]This is making a difference.

[00:01:05]I am at the Busaling Khidrpur Watganj Market right ahead of Bakri Eid the splendor of this market is missing according to visitors why so because of a 1950 law which the recently elected West Bengal Government has invoked ahead of the Bakri Eid according to this law cattle below the age of 14 cannot be slaughtered and for cattle above the age of 14 a fitness certificate is required. We spoke to both the visitors and traders of this market and they told us about the way they are following the guidelines of the West Bengal Government and those issued by the Maulanas of Bengal who have strictly asked Muslims of Bengal not to slaughter cows this Bakrid. But they also have asked some very potent questions. Keep on watching the video to find out. The price has increased. The price base has increased due to cows.

[00:02:06]So how much was it before? How are you now?

[00:02:08]Right now, it is making a bigger difference for the poor people.

[00:02:11]And it does n't make any difference to the middle class man.

[00:02:17]But whatever it is, it is making a difference. We are facing a lot of trouble because of cows and this makes a lot of difference.

[00:02:22]So how is it making a difference for the poor? You are saying that this is making a difference for poor people.

[00:02:27]If it was of a cow then what was in it? We used to have five to six shares in the cow and now we have only one share in this.

[00:02:33]Those five to six sacrifices were made on one cow. Only one man is having sex with one donkey.

[00:02:39]This is making a difference. So you are saying that earlier the cow used to be sacrificed, five or six together and one each, and now if the sacrifice is of a goat, then it is of only one person.

[00:02:53]Yes. So the poor suffered because of this.

[00:02:55]The pain has increased. And how much did it cost to own a cow earlier? The sacrifice in a cow used to be lumpsum, 80 to 90 thousand in a cow and 2000, 80 to 90 thousand in a male goat, those four to five people used to do it by dividing it together and in a male goat it is 25 to 30 thousand.

[00:03:17]Because of that one man, the prices have increased and the market does not have the same enthusiasm as it used to have, there is a lot of difference between now and before.

[00:03:26]Rest, we will do whatever is said about sacrifice, will we not sacrifice the cow?

[00:03:32]No, otherwise you are feeling bad about it or we are not feeling bad about it.

[00:03:37]Eating meat means we need meat and if you understand then you people are listening to the Maulana and this year there will be no sacrifice, no, it will not happen this year, we will do it this year, this is the law of the government, we all are Muslims, we have to follow the law, that is why we have to follow whatever the government says, we will not go against it, to please Allah we will give many rams, why will we give other camels also, that is why we will have to give cows, this is not right, this is not right, that is why for every Muslim, this animal which is for the Guru, cows should be banned for everyone, this should be banned for everyone, at least its name should be according to the breed of animal.

[00:04:42]This is what Muslims are saying that they will not allow us to sacrifice. That's ok.

[00:04:48]But it should not be exported either.

[00:04:51]He is selling it all over the world and here he is saying that it has no legal basis. Deep sacrifice is prohibited for Muslims. This is okay. We have accepted that every Muslim is total in West Bengal. That's fine. I am saying that this export from outside is not right. So how can the guru in our country go out? It will remain here for us and it will go out to give. There is a law for this.

[00:05:23]This is a very legal thing for you. You are right that whatever is for export should also be stopped. There should be equal laws for everyone.

[00:05:32]Only a law will be made for Muslims somewhere else and for Muslims here. There should be same law everywhere. So that's why it should be right to have a law.

[00:05:42]So this is your demand. What are you saying?

[00:05:44]Yes, that's why we don't have any demand. This is our sacrifice. Yes, you're saying that you're saying that if you guys are not eating. If you people agree then export should also be stopped.

[00:05:53]That animal must be a breed animal. It should be closed for everyone.

[00:05:59]This is not just to stop it in Bengal, this is the law of the government, every Muslim should follow it, will he accept it or will not accept it, okay, so this year most of the Muslims of Bengal will cough or will cough for the cow, you people have decided that you will not give it, no, you have taken the decision that you will not give it for the cow and we want to ban it nationally and people will not even eat it, what do you say, because of that, whatever you eat, in such times, even those who eat cows have stopped eating it completely, okay, no, we did not get any money advice, so we stopped eating cow in the khadal, this cough has started, there will be cough, there will be cough this time, this time it will be cough on Bakrid, and this will not happen every year, okay, it will happen every year, and tell me, those who sell cows, you must be familiar with them, they are saying that their condition is very bad, it is not that bad, they sell it to butchers, okay, okay, what do they do, I don't know, we sell a cow worth ₹1.5 lakh for 70,000, we have sold it and finished it, okay If the police comes and catches you, you will be put in jail and there will be trouble. I myself have come to buy a donkey.

[00:07:10]Everyone in our neighborhood has just come down to buy a donkey.

[00:07:14]Where have you come from?

[00:07:15]Tell me that. Okay, okay, and tell me how much would it have cost if you had bought a cow? There was more expense in cow.

[00:07:24]₹1 lakh becomes ₹1.5 lakh. Well, this will be less. How much will it cost?

[00:07:29]In this it will be done for at least Rs 60-7000.

[00:07:34]If you buy the best one, it will cost Rs 60-70,000.

[00:07:38]So this year, whatever you do during cough, you will sacrifice.

[00:07:44]Like in this, are the Muslim people happy or what? I am not happy but I will have to be happy even if I am not happy. The government has announced that if there is no cow then we will not give the cow, we are following the government's order but we do not want it, it is against the law, we will go for the sacrifice, the animal that is being sacrificed will do it, if we do not allow the cow to be sacrificed, we are from Etawah, you come here from UP, UP, UP to sell it every year in this market, and how much is it sold for here? You said that the goat of 70000, 70000, 75000, 400, 50000, for how much was this goat sold in front?

[00:08:30]25000 sold for 25000 only and that white one for 35000 35000 ok so this year like every year is there such splendor this year or is there splendor? It is a very nice glow. It is a great sight. There is excitement. It is very different from every other year.

[00:08:45]Because this time goats will sell more because cows will not be sold. It has not been sold. It is sold.

[00:08:52]We and the goat: This time there has been a lot of sale of goats during Eid. I am saying.

[00:08:59]This time it has happened more. And those who used to buy cows were also buying goats this time.

[00:09:07]Those people are also buying goats.

[00:09:10]Well, everyone is buying goats. You did not become a cowboy, someone bought all the goats.

[00:09:14]All the goats have been bought.

[00:09:16]And you people made good profits from this. Made a very good profit. Good profit, all the goats that come here come from UP.

[00:09:26]What is so special about the goat of UP?

[00:09:29]Gram is both long and elongated. Chota is also curried.

[00:09:34]Yes and that means it is bigger in size than the local goat here. They also keep better goods.

[00:09:39]We also keep good goods.

[00:09:41]And you are a Hindu. Sorry, you all are Hindus. The goats you sell here are mostly sold by Hindus. There are Hindu people. There are Hindu people.

[00:09:49]We are Hindu people.