In the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial, defense counsel raised concerns that accused individuals were being forced to use cold water despite previous court undertakings, which was affecting their health and ability to meaningfully participate in the proceedings. Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng exercised the court's inherent power to address this issue by ordering prison authorities to appear in court to resolve the matter, demonstrating how courts can intervene to ensure fair trial conditions when prison conditions compromise a defendant's health and capacity to participate in their defense.
Deep Dive
Prerequisite Knowledge
- No data available.
Where to go next
- No data available.
Deep Dive
ACCUSED SAYS COLD WATER IS MAKING HIM SICK | Judge Demands Answers | Senzo Meyiwa Trial
Added:You able?
Mr. Albasini.
Thank you.
Answer.
Okay.
Oh, good.
Is Mr. H.O.
>> H.L.
>> Oh, sorry. H.L.
>> Albasini.
>> Albasini.
How many years ago?
You know, I can't remember.
Yeah, okay.
Yes, yes, yes.
Yeah, fine.
You need requested postponement, obviously.
No, no, if you want time to read etc. You see how many decisions I've brought?
It's a serious matter, as you know.
So, if you need time, there's no hurry.
No problem. I'll grant you all the indulgence you you want.
Because the state's case, I'm sorry, the defense case for number two is not yet closed. So, we can continue with another witness in the meantime when you're preparing.
>> As a court leader, my lord, I wasn't anticipating >> Okay.
>> If I If I can advise the accused or the witness and just get his instruction on what he >> Yes.
>> intends doing.
>> Yes.
>> My lord, that's why I'm I I suspect and I don't want to get ahead of myself, but I suspect that it might be possible to dispense of this inquiry without having to have the inquiry.
>> Okay.
>> Depending on my instructions >> Yes, yes, fine. Fine.
>> That's why if if I have a view that more time more time I would have been able to advise your lordship >> Yeah.
>> um his position and his mind >> Yes. Okay, no no problem. What is the attitude of the state?
>> We We do not have any objection, my lord, if he can be given ample opportunity to consult with Mr. Buthelezi.
>> Okay.
>> [snorts] >> And the other counsels?
Mr. Ramusi P.
>> My lord, I think it is prudent that counsel for the witness be afforded an opportunity, my lord.
Mr. Mnisisi >> Are do do Mnisisi?
>> I have no objection.
>> No objection?
Okay, fine.
We are going on recess, is that not so?
>> Yes. That is correct, Mr. Chairman.
>> Starting on Monday?
>> Monday, yes.
>> Okay, so Where's Mr. Buthelezi?
Can you interpret what the counsel said so that he understands what's happening?
>> I >> I don't know. I did not go. No one gave me feedback.
>> So, you didn't attend court?
>> Our young advocate >> No.
>> Okay.
So, when do we postpone this matter to?
Can you arrange a date with your colleagues here?
After After consulting, obviously.
So, I will stand down until, let's say, 12:00 or 1:00.
What What do you intend doing?
Otherwise, I I can postpone it, and then you can arrange the date of the inquiry with uh the defense.
>> As court pleases, my lord, if we run into the term >> Yeah.
>> the term of my availability is limited, and then we might need to appoint somebody else.
Um But if we can make it standing down until after the uh with By that time, we must have an idea if it is going to be necessary to uh >> Okay.
>> the matter might be resolved without >> Yeah.
>> resorting to section 189.
>> Okay. Okay, fine.
>> As it pleases, my lord, before we adjourn, advocate Mncwabe indicated that you would like to place certain information on record.
>> Yeah. Okay.
As it pleases, the court >> Yes. This is the old issue that has been besetting accused number one relating to him using cold water every morning when he's supposed to come here.
>> Mhm.
>> He is saying that issue is still perpetuating or is continuing unabated to an extent that it's affecting his health.
He is telling me he's sick today.
He does not know whether he'll be in a position to be able to comprehend what is happening here because of his ill health, which is directly caused by him using cold water.
The court will recall that the Bingo was here and made certain undertakings. I don't know what is happening with those undertakings, but briefly that is what he's saying, my lords.
>> So, what do you intend doing now? What should we do?
Call the authorities to come to court or what?
>> Um my lords, they have been coming here.
Well, uh I would leave it in the hands of the court, my lord, because it is the court which can give a directive in this regard. If wishes were horses, I would I would beg that the position be changed so that his health is spared for him to come and have a meaningful participation in this trial.
That will cause a a non-delay of the trial, my lord. Unfortunately, I do not have that authority. It can only be It can only be a wishful thinking, but I think the court, with the inherent power that it has, can at least give a directive in this regard, my lords.
>> Can you arrange, Mr. Baloyi, for this I'll have to sacrifice and come on Monday here.
So, that the head of the prison should come here on Monday.
We'll postpone the matter to Monday. Is that okay?
Even if for you, Mr. Alberts, you can take your time and come on Monday if you think >> My lord, if I may I can request that they be Tuesday.
>> Tuesday, fine. Now, Tuesday. Okay, no problem.
Tuesday.
Okay.
>> Is it okay?
>> Okay, they can adjourn until then.
Mhm.
>> Before we adjourn, can I just assist my learned friend who is supposed to consult with the witness?
That we get an order, my lord, that the witness be not taken out to allow Mr. Advocate Hepworth to do a consultation here in court because last week on the adjournment you had a problem that the warders did not want to allow the consultation here because of some issues.
So, if there is a court order, my lord, that they they allow the consultation until I don't know how long how long.
Maybe until 1:00. That will Thank you.
>> I support this. Thank you. I thank you, Mr. Ronald.
My lord, yes, indeed. If I do not consult here and now, we are going to encounter the same problem which is that >> Okay, where are the the the gentlemen who are in charge?
Yeah.
Is it okay to stick around until 1:00?
Hello.
>> Yes.
>> How many are you? Two?
You're from where? Are you from Durban?
>> I'm from Durban.
>> So, you're here.
>> Yes.
>> So, there won't be problems.
What are the problems you think you are encountering?
Hello.
>> Hello. They are supposed to be in the management of the prison.
>> Who there?
>> Head of prison.
It's not a visit, it's a consultation.
Is it okay?
So, we can you assist with Mr. Alberts, the lawyer for Mr. Buthelezi.
So, that if you want to consult here or I don't know, in prison.
Then you you decide.
Yeah, so for me to make an appointment, travel to Port Shepstone or consulting there Okay, fine.
Okay, fine. Okay.
Okay, so the matter is then postponed to Tuesday.
The matter is then postponed to Tuesday.
Related Videos
JAMIA BA LLB 2026 Offline Mock Interview | Final Interview Round Preparation
MLSLAWACADEMY
104 views•2026-06-16
6/15/26 Lively v. Wayfarer - Full Settlement Agreement is now public
littlegirlattorney
11K views•2026-06-15
HOA Demolished My Yacht for “Unauthorized Docking” — Too Bad I Own the Entire Marina!
Pro-RevengeStories
423 views•2026-06-15
JACKSON KIHARA'S SECRET DEAL: The Deal That Brought Out Jackson Kihara From Jail | LifeLens TV
LifeLens254
5K views•2026-06-14
Guelph's New Renoviction By-Law Explained.
CallCodyRE
807 views•2026-06-14
SCOTUS Rules 9-0 on Gun Rights for Marijuana Users
TheReloadSite
164 views•2026-06-18
A Family Tradition of Federal Time
LoneWolfUsul
603 views•2026-06-14
YouTuber Alexander Zabel Jr arrested again near Nancy Guthrie’s home amid investigation disruption
StarBuzzHD
136 views•2026-06-15











