The Best $4 Pizza Money Can Buy

Added: 2026-05-25

[00:00:00]All right, today we're going to try out Wild Mike's ultimate pepperoni pizza.

[00:00:03]>> [music] >> It seems pretty easy to make as most frozen pizzas are. Simply take it out of the packaging and bake it at 400° for about 15 to 18 minutes. Right away, the first thing I notice is the amount of pepperoni. There's actually [music] a ton on here. They're not perfectly spread out or anything, but I definitely rather have too many than too few. The cheese also looks pretty thick, so hopefully that makes it taste a little bit more like an actual pizza [music] place instead of a cheap frozen one.

[00:00:24]We only have a toaster oven to cook this in, >> [music] >> so that may impact how it turns out compared to a regular oven, but hopefully it comes out good because so far [music] it actually looks pretty promising for a frozen pizza. All right, the frozen pizza just came out of the oven. Honestly, I don't even know how this happened. Somehow it's a little soggy and [music] burnt at the same time. The edges got pretty crispy, maybe a little too crispy, but [music] the middle's still kind of soft. I'm blaming the toaster oven for this one. But looks aside, it actually smells really good.

[00:00:49][music] The pepperoni got a nice crisp top and there's a ton of grease pulling up, which is either a terrible sign or a great sign depending on who you ask.

[00:00:56][music] Flavor-wise, this is actually pretty solid. The pepperoni has a nice salty, slightly spicy [music] flavor, and the cheese tastes better than most frozen pizzas. And the sauce is surprisingly decent. The texture is a little weird because of the soggy middle and [music] burnt crust combo, but the actual taste kind of makes up for it.

[00:01:11]Honestly, if you cook it a little more evenly than we did, this [music] would probably be really good. Definitely better than a lot of frozen pizzas I've had before. Overall rating, Wild Mike's ultimate [music] pizza gets a 7 out of 10.

[00:01:22]>> [laughter]