This video presents a theological debate where a Muslim speaker claims that the Quran confirms previous scriptures (Torah and Injil) while simultaneously teaching that Jesus was not crucified and did not rise from the dead, creating an apparent contradiction since Christian doctrine holds that Jesus was crucified and resurrected three days later. The speaker acknowledges they cannot answer who was crucified instead of Jesus, as the Quran does not specify this detail, highlighting what the speaker calls 'the Islamic dilemma' where the Quran confirms previous scriptures without providing detailed explanations of what to accept or reject from them.
Deep Dive
Prerequisite Knowledge
- No data available.
Where to go next
- No data available.
Deep Dive
“Muslims Will Fight Jews?” 😳 Shocking Judgment Day Claim… Then Ish Asks “Who Died on the Cross?” ✝️Added:
Before the day of judgement will come, he will return.
He will be from the prophet Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam's basically army. Okay. That's what we believe. So, there will be a great war.
It's called the Malhama.
That's going to be between the Muslims and the Jews.
And the signs of the hour are already here. Who was crucified instead of Jesus? It says in the Quran that they they made it to appear that you know Isa was crucified. Who was in replacement of him? Who was put in the place of Isa?
And I I got I got a question about the Islamic dilemma. What do you think about the Islamic dilemma?
What do you think about the Islamic dilemma?
What Islamic dilemma? So, the Hadith Quran confirms the previous scriptures.
I agree with it.
So, like if Allah has said That's creative.
Both in revelation. Yeah.
And he's saying clearly equally he's saying his name.
He's saying that he sent the word and the message of La ilaha illallah Yeah.
Okay. I'll tell you why.
He said La ilaha illallah and whatever prophet was there.
Okay.
For Jews first.
He gave the Torah to them. Mhm.
They still follow that.
Then the Christians, Allah bless them too.
He gave them the Injil, the Old Testament. Do you believe that we still have the Injil and Torah in this present day and age? I feel it's there. Do you do you believe it's the same? I I feel it's not the same from the versions that we've got now.
But I feel that there is one that we're saying on the documentary.
Where does the Quran say that? Where does the Where does the Quran say like what to read from the Torah and what not to read from the Injil?
So, what to So, I'm not too sure on that. What I do know is you have to accept as a Muslim that the Torah and the Injil are from Allah. So, if if as a Muslim that you you So, the last revelation So, if if as a Muslim you accept the Torah, you accept [laughter] the Injil, right? And that the creator The thing that I don't really agree with how you the Muslims say that the ones that we have today is not in the current form.
>> [laughter] >> But we have manuscripts, right? We have manuscripts of the Torah and the Injil.
We have we have manuscripts of the Torah and Injil dating from the 4th century.
[laughter] Muhammad existed around 6th century. So how can we say there's change? We have we have manuscripts that are the same from today as they were in the 4th century. So how can you say it's changed? I'm not saying it's changed.
I'm saying that the books that we have now, the Bible now, as opposed to the past.
Are the Christian faith. Okay. And they're quite renowned.
They have said to me on a personal level when we had debates so space with them.
That they also believe that there's verses taken out of the Bible. But could you show me and added in. Can you show me main any main doctrines that have been changed? Because the main doctrine Okay, this is the thing, right? The main doctrine of Christianity The main doctrine of Christianity Wait, let me say one thing. I'm saying one thing before you say this.
I have no knowledge to give justice to your Qu'ran. Okay. But this is this is the The main doctrine of Christianity is that Christ was God, he was the son of God, that he was crucified, and he rose from the grave 3 days later. This is the main doctrine of Christianity.
And scholars say that the main doctrine of Christianity has not been changed.
It's same through all the manuscripts.
So how can you say like the How can you say it's been changed in any any sort of way?
>> We believe that God is one.
Yeah, he doesn't have any attachments to the worldly life, the dunya.
We believe that he's one. So when he when we say that he's one, we say that he's free from Father, the Son, the Holy Ghost. And Jesus himself said, "I'm nothing without he, the Father."
So you're not you're not understanding the the main point The main point is that the main doctrines of Christianity has not been changed. And your Qu'ran is agreeing with that, which is a big dilemma. Right, okay. So what I'm saying to you is is I'm going to have to research this.
I can't just give you a straight answer.
I'll be lying.
I'll definitely go and research this and I'll come back. Because if Christ if Jesus Christ had not risen from the dead, if he did not if he was not crucified, then Christianity would be dead. And that doctrine is the same throughout all the manuscripts, and your Quran is agreeing with that. The Quran is agreeing with that. It's a big problem because your Quran said he was he neither was crucified or he neither rose from the dead. And the main manuscript your Quran is agreeing with says that that he was crucified and he rose from the dead. That's a big dilemma you have. No, we don't say that he died.
But the manuscripts say that. The manuscripts Which manuscripts? The codex Sinaiticus, the codex Alexandrinus, the Peshitta That's not our book. But your Quran is is it confirmed again? We don't believe So what does it say in Surah 3:43?
Confirm what they have with them. Let me tell you something. We don't believe that Jesus Islam he was dead on a cross, okay? We believe that he was risen and preserved in Jannah to the day of Yom al-Qiyamah.
Before the day of judgment will come, he will return.
He will be from the Prophet Muhammad Islam's basically army. Okay.
>> That's what we believe. So, there will be a great war called the Malhama.
That's going to be between the Muslims and the Jews.
And the signs of the hour are already here.
So we're seeing them. So how If if I want to find out if if I [laughter] as an atheist or if I as a Muslim want to find out more about Jesus's life, where would I go to in the 4th century? Where would I go Read Surah Maryam in the Quran. But that's not You don't You don't You don't see much about Jesus's life. But if you if you read it Okay, I'll give you information. Who was crucified instead of Jesus? It says in the Quran that they that they made to appear that you know Isa was crucified.
Who was in replacement of him? Who was put in the place of Isa? You tell me.
I'm asking you. Your Quran is revealed I don't know this. Because okay, the this is the the Quran >> is that he is not dead. The Quran is revealed is a is a detailed explanation.
It's a confirmation of the previous books. It's come to correct the previous books. That's what you guys claim. So where does the Quran say he was crucified instead of Isa?
Brother Let me say something.
>> It's a >> [laughter] >> It's a big problem you have. It's a big problem.
It's a big problem. This is funny. Who was crucified instead of Who was crucified instead of Isa?
Yeah, who was it? Who was crucified instead of Isa In the Quran.
In the Quran.
Where does it say in the Quran? Okay, so that's that's the big problem you have.
So, I don't want to be lying.
You were talking to I don't want to lie if I say I don't have this information.
I have to go back to the drawing board.
I don't have it.
Okay. Cuz it won't be a job.
I don't want to give unjust to you. I don't want to give unjust to myself.
But don't you think how it was weird how there's many prophecies in the Old Testament about this Messiah coming to die for our sins, to come back from the grave three days later, and then Jesus comes, right, 700 years later, 500 years later. He has many witnesses that saw him crucified, and then they see him come back from the grave three days later, and then the tomb was empty.
Yeah, yeah, so why was the tomb empty?
Do you do you believe that Jesus is God?
Yes. But why was the tomb empty? I want to ask you a question. Okay, yeah. Do you believe that Jesus is God?
Okay, so who was he praying to? Yeah, he was praying to God the Father in his humanity.
No, that can't be the case. You can't be praying Cuz Christ was a servant as well, right? No, he's praying to the Father. Brother, who's the Father? The first person of the Trinity.
Right, that's according to your latest edition. According to the Bible. Right, so this Trinity came how long after Jesus? It was in the Bible in the Old Testament. Isaiah 48:16. You see it there. Isaiah 63:10 as well. But was it mentioned in the time of Isa Islam? Uh yeah, Jesus mentioned the Trinity. He said, "In baptizing them in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit."
Matthew 28:19. Okay, and how long after his death was this This was existed before him. This is This was existed when he was on Earth before he ascended to heaven. Okay. So, he was preaching the triune So, why are you arguing with me? I don't get it. I'm preaching to you how your religion is a big problem. You can't preach to me. I'm Muslim. Yeah, but there's a big dilemma.
Your Quran is confirming our scriptures.
Our scriptures say that Christ was crucified and he rose from the grave three days later. Your Quran completely says that he was not crucified or he rose from the dead. But then again, it confirms the previous scriptures. Do you believe he was crucified?
Absolutely, yes. testament. Yes, it's meant to be. We say that there's the Old Testament, New Testament, and then the Quran is the last testament >> Okay. to humanity. Prophet Muhammad even Abdullah, he came down for the whole of humanity.
>> So, why is it confirming what is with them between the hands?
One second. He's called the prophet in our religion. We believe that his purpose was just merely a message. I I go to the house of He came to send a message of But why was it Why was Why is the Quran confirming what is with them between the hands?
But I would rather you speak to Yaseen.
That's He just want to speak. But you you don't know the answer to it. On this occasion on this topic you can I don't want to give injustice. Okay, that's fine. I respect. I I draw the I draw the board then. God bless. God bless. God bless.
I draw the board.
Yeah.
We We talked about the Islamic dilemma.
They can't answer the Islamic dilemma.
Then he went went on to about the couldn't answer who was crucified instead of Isa. They believe Judas was crucified, but nowhere in the Quran does it say that. So, again it's a big dilemma because the Quran is confirming the previous scriptures. It doesn't tell us what to go what to read from the previous scriptures what not to read. It doesn't give us a detailed explanation.
You know, it's a big dilemma they have no answer to it.
Related Videos
BSA Goldstar - I gave up! And why animals beat humans!
thebingleywheeler
102 views•2026-05-31
The 'Islamic dilemma': Quran tells Christians to judge by the Gospel
canceledkings
1K views•2026-05-29
Letter to An Ex-Muslim
FarhanAhmedZia
5K views•2026-05-29
Seneca - Escape The Crowd, Find Your Inner Peace!
realfreewisdom
114 views•2026-05-29
Scholar Explains: WHAT IS A GNOSTIC?
fightbackpodcast
965 views•2026-05-31
Fulton Sheen: A Mente Tenta se Manter Jovem para não Sofrer com os Impactos do Tempo
SantoCotidiano-port
673 views•2026-05-29
Everyone is sprinting towards nothing.
ElinJen
2K views•2026-05-29
The fourth great humiliation. #jimmycarr #crowdwork #hecklers #standup
jimmycarr
576K views•2026-05-28











