Dismantling assumptions about Christianity

本站添加: 2026-05-27

[00:00:00]Human sin and the whole free will kind of argument doesn't it doesn't make any sense. All right, let's get into it. So, who created sin?

[00:00:09]And then if you say it's Satan, who created Satan?

[00:00:13]Man and the angels were created in a state of innocence. They chose to break fellowship with God. God did not choose that for them. If I created a new car and then I gave it to you and then you went ahead and destroyed it, it wouldn't make sense to say I created a destroyed car. In the same way, it doesn't make any sense to say that God created sin.

[00:00:30]He already knows the decisions that people will make before he creates them.

[00:00:34]My fate and your fate were pre-decided before we even got to say so. God's foreknowledge does not affect our free will. God's knowledge is like a barometer. The barometer has no effect on the weather, it just knows it.

[00:00:46]There's no causal relationship between God's foreknowledge and our actions. I'm raising my hand. Suppose that I did not raise my hand, God would have foreknown that. God's foreknowledge is logically dependent on our free choice, it has no effect on it. Philosophers call this kind of reasoning a modal scope fallacy.

[00:01:01]Does that make any Does that make any sense? Like you you just see No, it does not, like all of your other arguments.

[00:01:06]God bless.