Every Female Inmate On Death Row: Full Details & Shocking Crimes

Ajouté : 2026-05-27

[00:00:05]Angela Menalti.

[00:00:07]On December 9th, 2009, paramedics rushed into a home in Eugene, Oregon, expecting to treat a sick teenager.

[00:00:16]What they found instead was a 15-year-old girl who appeared to be already dead. Her mother, Angela Mcceni, told them the girl had been fine just an hour earlier.

[00:00:29]Paramedics did not believe her. Neither did anyone else who walked through that door.

[00:00:35]The girl was Janette Maples, and what investigators would uncover in the weeks that followed made this case one of the most disturbing in Oregon's history.

[00:00:47]Angela McCanny would become the only woman ever sentenced to death in the state of Oregon since capital punishment was reinstated in 1984.

[00:00:57]And somehow it gets worse.

[00:01:01]Janette had been born into instability.

[00:01:04]She had been removed from Angela's custody once before back in California when child welfare agencies flagged the home as dangerous. But the system that was supposed to protect her sent her back.

[00:01:18]The family relocated to Oregon in 2002 and for a time Janette attended public school.

[00:01:26]Teachers noticed signs of abuse and reported them.

[00:01:30]Oregon's Department of Human Services opened an investigation, visited the home, and spoke with Angela, who dismissed every concern by calling her daughter a compulsive liar.

[00:01:44]The agency accepted that explanation.

[00:01:47]Angela then pulled Janette out of school entirely, cutting off the last adults who had been watching.

[00:01:54]With Janette now isolated from teachers, counselors, and any outside contact, the abuse escalated behind closed doors.

[00:02:04]Prosecutors later told the court that the mistreatment was methodical and prolonged, lasting months.

[00:02:12]Court filings described what happened as deliberate and premeditated. The autopsy found injuries consistent with prolonged abuse, starvation, infection, and severe neglect.

[00:02:25]By the time paramedics arrived, the scope of what had been done to Janette was staggering. She showed extensive signs of abuse, and the physical neglect alone had left her body in a condition that shocked even experienced first responders.

[00:02:41]Stepfather Richard McCannalty pleaded guilty to murder by abuse in 2011 and received life in prison with the possibility of parole after 25 years.

[00:02:54]Angela's case went differently.

[00:02:56]On the first day of her February 2011 trial in Lane County Circuit Court, she pleaded guilty with no agreement from prosecutors to take the death penalty off the table. Her own attorneys, Kenneth Hadley and Steven Cassich, had advised her to do this without securing any concessions from the state. It was a decision that would later be ruled a catastrophic legal error. The penalty phase lasted two weeks. A jury of eight men and four women heard testimony about what had been done to Janette, and they returned a death sentence in roughly 6 hours. The district attorney at the time, Alex Gardner, later acknowledged how difficult the process had been for the jurors, noting that they had not volunteered for jury duty, but were drafted into it, and that the fact they stood up and fulfilled their obligation was extraordinary.

[00:03:54]Angela's conviction was affirmed by the Oregon Supreme Court in 2014.

[00:04:00]But in July of 2019, postconviction judge J. Berdett Pratt vacated both the conviction and the death sentence.

[00:04:10]The ruling found that Angela's trial attorneys had been ineffective for advising her to plead guilty without obtaining any concessions and for failing to investigate mitigation evidence that could have influenced the sentencing outcome. The state appealed and in 2020 prosecutors reached a settlement.

[00:04:30]Angela dropped her appeal of the conviction and in exchange the death sentence was vacated.

[00:04:37]Lane County District Attorney Patty Pllo confirmed the outcome stating that the agreement provided for the death sentence to be removed and replaced with life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. Angela Mcceni remains in prison today. She will never be released.

[00:04:56]Janette Maples was 15 years old. She had been pulled out of school, cut off from every person who might have helped her, and subjected to conditions that multiple officials had been warned about and failed to stop. Her case led to scrutiny of Oregon's child protective system, but for Janette, that scrutiny came far too late. You would think that a case this severe would be rare among women on death row. It is not.

[00:05:27]And the next woman on this list has spent nearly 30 years fighting a conviction that, depending on who you ask, either put a guilty mother behind bars or destroyed an innocent one.

[00:05:41]Darly Routier.

[00:05:44]In the early morning hours of June 6th, 1996, Darly Routier called 911 from her home on Eagle Drive in Rowlet, Texas, screaming that an intruder had broken in through the garage and stabbed her two sons.

[00:06:01]Six-year-old Devon was pronounced dead at the scene. 5-year-old Damon died on the way to the hospital.

[00:06:09]Darly herself had stab wounds to her throat, arm, and shoulder. It should have been a straightforward home invasion case. Instead, it became one of the most contested murder convictions in Texas history. And nearly 30 years later, DNA testing is still ongoing.

[00:06:29]When detectives processed the crime scene, the intruder theory started falling apart almost immediately.

[00:06:37]There was no blood in the garage where the supposed attacker had entered. The dust on the window sill was undisturbed.

[00:06:45]The mulch beneath the cut window screen outside had not been stepped in. A bloody tube sock containing blood from both boys was found in an alley about 75 yards from the house and it matched socks from the Rutier home. Prosecutors built their case around a theory that Darly had stabbed her sons, broken a wine glass to simulate a struggle, sliced through the window screen herself, planted the sock in the alley, and then inflicted wounds on her own body to stage the scene.

[00:07:20]Blood spatter on the back of her night shirt, they argued, was consistent with a downward stabbing motion. The timeline was tight and the defense leaned heavily on that.

[00:07:32]Pathology estimated that Damon could have survived for only about 9 minutes after being wounded.

[00:07:39]The 911 call lasted 6 minutes and police arrived roughly a minute after it ended.

[00:07:46]That left approximately 2 minutes for Darly to have carried out the entire staging scenario, including cleaning up, slashing the screen, running a sock to the alley, and inflicting her own injuries.

[00:08:00]Her attorneys argued that was physically impossible, but the evidence that may have hurt Darly the most had nothing to do with forensics.

[00:08:09]Eight days after the murders, on what would have been Devon's seventh birthday, a local television crew filmed Darly and her family at the boy's grave site. The grave was covered in balloons.

[00:08:23]Darly was laughing, spraying silly string, and singing Happy Birthday.

[00:08:29]The clip was played for jurors, and its impact was devastating.

[00:08:36]Dallas County Prosecutor Greg Davis later said the footage disturbed him deeply, noting that it had only been a week since the boys died, and yet there was a full birthday celebration happening at the grave site.

[00:08:50]What the jury did not see was the portion of the footage filmed minutes before in which Darly and her family were crying and praying. Only the celebratory segment was introduced at trial.

[00:09:03]Darly later explained that Devon had wanted to turn seven and she had done the only thing she could think of to honor him.

[00:09:11]She asked how anyone could know how they would behave in that situation.

[00:09:16]The trial was moved to Carville on a change of venue and Darly was charged only with Damon's murder. Devon's case was held in legal reserve. The jury convicted her and on February 4th, 1997, she was sentenced to death. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals upheld the conviction in 2003.

[00:09:40]And no, I'm not making that up. Nearly three decades on death row, and the case is still not settled.

[00:09:48]Renewed DNA and fingerprint testing began in 2008.

[00:09:52]A bloody fingerprint found on a coffee table at the scene was run through Aphus in 2019 and returned no match, meaning it belonged to someone not in the system. Additional DNA analysis was ordered as recently as 2018, and results remain pending as of 2026.

[00:10:13]Her ex-husband, Darren Rutier, has publicly maintained her innocence throughout.

[00:10:19]The Dallas County Conviction Integrity Unit continues to evaluate the evidence.

[00:10:24]Darly Rutier's case has been featured in multiple documentaries, including The Last Defense on ABC in 2018 and Death Rows Women on ITV in 2020.

[00:10:37]Darly Rutier sits on death row at the Patrick L. Oo Daniel unit in Gatesville, Texas. No execution date has ever been set. After nearly 30 years, the question of what happened inside that house on Eagle Drive remains one of the most divisive in American true crime. But if Darly Rutier's case is defined by what might not have happened, the next case on this list leaves no room for doubt about what did.

[00:11:07]Brittany Hullberg.

[00:11:10]On the night of November 13th, 1996, 80-year-old AB Towery Senior was killed inside his apartment in Southwest Amarillo, Texas. His son Rocky found the body the next morning.

[00:11:25]The scene was one of the most violent investigators in Randall County had ever processed.

[00:11:30]Towery suffered 58 stab wounds inflicted by a pairing knife, a butcher knife, a grapefruit knife, and two forks.

[00:11:40]He had blunt force injuries from a hammer, a cast iron skillet, and a steam iron. And an 11in lamp pole had been forced approximately 5 in down his throat while he was still alive.

[00:11:54]He was 80 years old and in declining health when it happened.

[00:11:59]The woman responsible was 23-year-old Brittany Hullberg, a sex worker struggling with a severe crack cocaine addiction who had been on a downward spiral for years.

[00:12:11]Hullberg had arrived at Towry's apartment after fleeing a minor traffic accident earlier that evening.

[00:12:18]Towry had been a client in the past.

[00:12:20]According to Hullberg's trial testimony, the encounter turned violent after Towry struck her with a frying pan when he found her smoking crack in his apartment, and she claimed she lost control only after he grabbed her by the hair and pulled out a clump. What followed went far beyond any plausible claim of self-defense.

[00:12:42]The sheer number of weapons used, the variety of injuries, and the duration of the attack pointed to something far more deliberate than a panicked reaction.

[00:12:53]After the killing, Hullberg showered, changed into clean clothes belonging to Towery, took $1,400 from his wallet, placed the wallet on his chest, and left the apartment.

[00:13:07]She fled to Memphis, Tennessee.

[00:13:10]After the case was featured on America's Most Wanted, she was arrested outside a McDonald's on February 17th, 1997, more than three months after the murder.

[00:13:22]At trial in March of 1998, the state's most critical witness was Vicky Marie Kirkpatre, Hullberg's jail cellmate.

[00:13:31]Kirkpatrick testified that Hullberg had called the killing fun and amazing and bragged that she would do it all over again if it meant getting more drugs.

[00:13:41]That testimony was delivered with apparent sincerity and the jury convicted Hullberg before Judge Patrick Purle in the 251st District Court and sentenced her to death.

[00:13:54]That's not a typo, by the way. A cellmate's testimony was the lynchpin of the state's case at sentencing. And what prosecutors did not tell the jury and did not tell the defense was that Kirk Patrick was a paid confidential informant for Amarillo police.

[00:14:13]She had been released on bond the very same day she gave her statement implicating Hullberg.

[00:14:20]That fact was never disclosed.

[00:14:23]Kirk Patrick recanted her testimony in 2011, saying she had fabricated the most damaging details.

[00:14:31]Federal courts later confirmed the suppression of evidence. In March of 2025, a fifth circuit panel vacated Hullberg's conviction in a 2 to1 ruling finding a Brady violation. Judge Patrick Higinbotham writing for the majority stated that prosecutors had presented Kirkpatrick to the jury as a disinterested individual who simply wanted to do the right thing when in reality she was anything but disinterested.

[00:15:02]The dissenting judge Steuart Kyle Duncan argued that the physical evidence alone was so overwhelming that impeaching Kirkpatrick would not have changed the outcome.

[00:15:14]pointing to the forensic findings as proof that Hullberg's self-defense theory was doomed regardless of who testified.

[00:15:22]In July of 2025, the full fifth circuit granted rehering on Bon reinstating the conviction while the case was reargued.

[00:15:33]Oral arguments were heard on January 21st, 2026.

[00:15:39]Brittany Hullberg remains on death row and her case is still unresolved. Her attorney, David Abernathy, has argued that the suppression of Kirkpatrick's informant status unquestionably affected the sentencing decision.

[00:15:55]The former Randall County District Attorney, James Faren, publicly stated the case had cost the county at least $400,000 and that he would no longer routinely seek the death penalty except in narrow circumstances.

[00:16:11]Hullberg's legal fight may still be years from resolution, but the next woman on this list is running out of time. Her execution is scheduled, and if it goes forward, she will be the first woman put to death in Tennessee in more than 200 years.

[00:16:31]Chris Pike. On the night of January 12th, 1995, three students from the Knoxville Job Corps program lured a classmate to a remote pathway on the University of Tennessee's agricultural campus. The supposed reason was to smoke marijuana together. The real reason was jealousy over a boy. 18-year-old Christa Pike, her 17-year-old boyfriend, Tateral Ship, and 18-year-old Shadala Peterson had invited 19-year-old Colleen Sleur, a fellow JobCore student originally from Florida, to join them for what seemed like a casual evening.

[00:17:12]SLMur and Pike were acquaintances, and Pike suspected SLMur had romantic interest in ship.

[00:17:20]That suspicion was enough.

[00:17:23]What Slmer walked into was an ambush that lasted somewhere between 30 minutes and an hour. Pike and ship attacked SLMur with a small meat cleaver and a box cutter, slicing and beating her repeatedly over a prolonged period.

[00:17:39]They finished by bludgeoning her skull with a chunk of asphalt ripped from the ground. After SLMur was dead, Pike kept a piece of her skull as a trophy.

[00:17:50]The next morning at breakfast in the JobCore cafeteria, she reportedly told other students that she was eating her meal alongside it. Pike was tried in 1996 before Judge Mary Beth Lieowitz in Knox County.

[00:18:07]The jury deliberated only a few hours before returning a conviction for firstdegree murder and conspiracy.

[00:18:15]She was sentenced to death, making her the youngest woman sentenced to death in the United States since the Supreme Court's Furman decision in 1972.

[00:18:26]She was 18 at the time of the crime and 19 at sentencing.

[00:18:32]Tadarl Ship received life with the possibility of parole. He was denied parole in October of 2025 and his next review will not come until 2031.

[00:18:46]Shadala Peterson received probation after cooperating with prosecutors and testifying for the state. Colleen SLMur's mother, Mayor, has spent decades fighting for the return of her daughter's skull fragment, which the state of Tennessee retained as evidence and has not released. For Marines, the legal proceedings have never truly ended. Every appeal, every hearing, every delay has reopened the wound.

[00:19:15]You'd think someone would have said something. Nobody did. Not when Pike bragged about the killing to classmates the following morning. Not when she reportedly showed a piece of the victim's skull to other students.

[00:19:29]The confession came within days, not because anyone in the dormatory reported what they had seen and heard, but because investigators closed in through standard police work.

[00:19:41]Pike's behavior on death row only reinforced the severity of her sentence.

[00:19:46]On August 24th, 2001, she strangled fellow inmate Patricia Jones with a shoestring and nearly killed her.

[00:19:56]She was convicted of attempted first-degree murder in 2004.

[00:20:01]Twice in 2001 and 2002, Pike filed motions to drop all of her appeals and accept execution.

[00:20:11]Both times she later reversed course and continued fighting. Her defense filings over the years have centered on fetal alcohol brain damage, sexual abuse during childhood, and the fact that she has spent nearly 30 years in what amounts to solitary confinement.

[00:20:29]In September of 2024, a settlement granted her access to general population for the first time since her incarceration.

[00:20:39]Her attorney, Angela Bergman, noted that Pike had been kept in a cell roughly the size of a parking space for almost three decades with nearly no meaningful human contact.

[00:20:51]As of 2026, Christa Pike's execution is scheduled for September 30th.

[00:20:59]She filed a federal lawsuit on January 8th, 2026 challenging Tennessee's pentobarbital execution protocol on 8th amendment and religious liberty grounds. If the execution proceeds as scheduled, she will be the first woman executed in the state of Tennessee in over 200 years.

[00:21:21]The story of Christa Pike is one of extreme violence committed at a shockingly young age, followed by decades of legal battles that have done nothing to undo what happened on that pathway in Knoxville.

[00:21:34]But the next case takes a very different shape. It is not about sudden rage or youthful violence. It is about patience, planning, and nearly 300 letters that spelled out exactly what was going to happen.

[00:21:51]Donna Roberts.

[00:21:53]Investigators do not usually get to hear a murder being planned in real time. In the case of Donna Roberts, they got something close.

[00:22:03]19 recorded jail phone calls and nearly 300 letters between Roberts and her incarcerated lover Nathaniel Jackson laid out the plot to kill her longtime partner Robert Fingerhut in detail that left almost nothing to interpretation.

[00:22:20]On December 11th, 2001, Robert Finger Hut, 57 years old, was ambushed and fatally shot inside the Howland Township home he shared with Roberts in Trumbull County, Ohio.

[00:22:34]The trigger man was Nathaniel Jackson, who had carried out the killing just 2 days after being released from prison on an unrelated charge. The motive was straightforward.

[00:22:46]Finger Hut had life insurance policies worth more than $500,000, and Roberts was the beneficiary.

[00:22:54]Roberts had done more than just plan the killing from a distance. She purchased a mask and gloves for Jackson before his release and arranged for him to enter the home on the night of the murder. The recorded calls and letters recovered by investigators during Jackson's earlier incarceration painted a picture of two people who had discussed every detail of what they intended to do, when they intended to do it, and what they expected to gain from it. To put it in the simplest possible terms, they wrote the plan down and said it out loud on a recorded phone line repeatedly over a period of months.

[00:23:34]Both Roberts and Jackson were tried before Trumbull County Common Please Judge John Stewart.

[00:23:40]First Assistant Christopher Becker led the prosecution.

[00:23:44]Jackson was convicted and sentenced to death. Roberts was convicted of complicity to aggravated murder, aggravated burglary, aggravated robbery, and conspiracy. And she also received a death sentence.

[00:24:00]What followed was one of the longest and most procedurally tangled appellet battles in Ohio's capital punishment history.

[00:24:08]The Ohio Supreme Court vacated Roberts's death sentence the first time because Judge Stewart had allowed prosecutors to help draft the sentencing opinion. The sentence was reimposed. It was vacated again in 2013 because the court had failed to properly consider her alocution. the defendant's right to address the court before sentencing. It was reimposed again. Through all of this, her conviction was never overturned.

[00:24:39]Justice Terrence O'Donnell, writing for the Ohio Supreme Court majority in 2017, found that Roberts had aided and emedded the aggravated murder with prior calculation and design. In August of 2023, federal judge Dan Pollster denied her habius petition in a 120page opinion that addressed every issue raised by the defense.

[00:25:05]Trumbull County Assistant Prosecutor Chuck Marorrow said at the time that Judge Pollster had conducted a thorough analysis and that the prosecution was satisfied none of the defense claims had merit.

[00:25:19]Then in May of 2025, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ordered Roberts to be resentenced.

[00:25:27]The court cited the same judicial bias and excluded mitigation findings it had previously used to vacate Nathaniel Jackson's death sentence. Jackson's resentencing was scheduled for February of 2026 before Judge Ronald J. Rice. Roberts's resentencing timeline has not yet been set, and Trumbull County prosecutor Dennis Watkins has called this his strongest death penalty case. The guilt itself has never been in dispute. The letters exist. The phone calls exist.

[00:26:02]The insurance policies exist. The mask and gloves were purchased. Donna Roberts is 81 years old. Her conviction stands.

[00:26:14]Only the question of whether she will die in prison under a death sentence or under a life sentence remains unresolved.

[00:26:22]If you are enjoying this video, consider subscribing. It really does help the channel grow and it lets me keep making these.

[00:26:32]Brenda Andrew.

[00:26:34]On November 20th, 2001, Robert Andrew pulled into the garage of his home in the Edmund area of Oklahoma City to pick up his children for Thanksgiving visitation.

[00:26:46]His aranged wife, Brenda, had asked him to come inside and light the furnace pilot. When he stepped through the door, a 16 gauge shotgun was leveled at him from across the garage. Rob grabbed the nearest thing he could find, a trash bag full of aluminum cans, and held it up as a shield.

[00:27:06]The first blast tore through it. The second was fired at close range. Rob Andrew was 39 years old. He was an advertising executive. He had come to his own home to collect his kids for the holiday. He never made it back outside.

[00:27:24]Brenda called 911 and told the dispatcher that two masked men had attacked them. She had a superficial 22 caliber wound to her arm, which prosecutors would later argue was self-inflicted as part of the staging.

[00:27:39]Investigators were skeptical from the start, and the deeper they looked, the worse it got for Brenda Andrew.

[00:27:46]The codefendant was James Pavat, the family's insurance agent and a fellow Sunday school teacher at the local Baptist church.

[00:27:56]Pavat had been having an affair with Brenda since at least August of 2001.

[00:28:01]He had also sold Rob an $800,000 life insurance policy, naming Brenda as the sole beneficiary.

[00:28:10]When Rob discovered the affair and tried to remove Brenda from the policy, she and Pavat forged his signature to keep ownership intact.

[00:28:20]Phone records from the weeks before the shooting showed 82 calls between Brenda and Pavat in a single day.

[00:28:28]There had already been one earlier attempt on Rob's life.

[00:28:33]Someone cut his brake lines and Pavat's daughter, Janna Larson, placed decoy phone calls to help set up the ambush.

[00:28:41]That attempt failed.

[00:28:44]After the shooting, Brenda and Pavat fled to Mexico with the children. They were arrested at the border roughly 3 months later.

[00:28:53]Pavat confessed and was sentenced to death, though he denied that Brenda had been involved.

[00:29:00]The evidence said otherwise and prosecutors charged them both.

[00:29:05]Brenda Andrew was convicted in 2004 and sentenced to death.

[00:29:11]She is the only woman on Oklahoma's death row. What made this trial so controversial was not the question of guilt. It was how the prosecution chose to make its case.

[00:29:24]Lead prosecutor Galen Guyger introduced extensive testimony about Brenda's extrammarital affairs, her clothing choices, sexual behavior in her car, and her parenting.

[00:29:36]During closing arguments, Guyger pulled a pair of thong underwear from Brenda's suitcase, displayed it to the jury, and asked whether a grieving widow would pack something like that.

[00:29:48]He referred to her during the trial using a degrading sexual slur. Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals Judge A.

[00:29:57]Johnson dissented in part, writing that the prosecution had engaged in a pattern of introducing evidence that served no purpose other than to hammer home that Brenda Andrew was a bad wife, a bad mother, and a bad woman. Judge Chapel would have reversed the conviction entirely.

[00:30:16]The case reached the United States Supreme Court on January 21st, 2025.

[00:30:23]The court ruled 7 to2 in Andrew versus White, vacating the 10th Circuit's decision and remanding for reconsideration of Brenda's due process claim. The unsigned opinion held that the due process clause prohibits the introduction of evidence so unduly prejuditial that it renders a criminal trial fundamentally unfair.

[00:30:48]Justices Thomas and Gorsuch dissented.

[00:30:51]Oklahoma's attorney general expressed disappointment but maintained that there was overwhelming evidence of the conspiracy to murder Rob Andrew.

[00:31:02]The case is now back before the 10th Circuit, which must decide whether the evidence introduced at trial crossed that constitutional line. The conviction stands for now, but Brenda Andrews legal fight is far from over. $800,000 in life insurance, 82 phone calls in one day, a forged signature, and a shotgun in a garage.

[00:31:27]That was the plan. And as calculated as it was, the next case on this list involves a killing motivated by something even more coldly practical.

[00:31:39]Silencing a witness.

[00:31:43]Kimberly Cargill.

[00:31:45]Cherry Walker was 39 years old and had an intellectual disability that left her functioning at roughly the cognitive level of a 9-year-old.

[00:31:55]She lived semi-independently with a half-day caregiver, held down basic responsibilities, and earned extra money babysitting for families in her community.

[00:32:06]One of her regular clients was a licensed vocational nurse named Kimberly Cargill, who paid Walker to watch her four-year-old son.

[00:32:15]Cherry Walker trusted Kimberly Cargill.

[00:32:18]That trust would cost her everything.

[00:32:21]On June 18th, 2010, Cherry Walker was served with a subpoena to testify at Cargill's child custody hearing, which was scheduled for 5 days later. The hearing involved allegations that Cargill was an unfit mother, and Walker's testimony was expected to be damaging.

[00:32:40]Walker never made it to that courtroom.

[00:32:42]She was killed that same day.

[00:32:45]Cargill killed Walker by asphyxiation, drove the body to a remote stretch of Oscar Burquette Road in Smith County, Texas, dowsed it in lighter fluid, and set it on fire. Walker's father, Guthrie Walker, identified the partially burned remains on Father's Day of 2010.

[00:33:06]One of the crulest coincidences in a case full of cruelty.

[00:33:11]The lead prosecutor, Matt Bingham, would later describe the case as a Cinderella story gone horribly wrong. The motive required no speculation.

[00:33:22]Cargill was in the middle of an ugly custody battle that involved ongoing CPS investigations into her treatment of her own children.

[00:33:32]Phone records showed a series of increasingly hostile calls between Cargill and Child Protective Services personnel in the days leading up to the murder. 9 hours after Walker was served with the subpoena, Cargill called the district attorney's office. Cherry Walker had already told her supervisor, Partina Young, that Cargill had threatened to hide her away so she would not be able to testify.

[00:33:58]That warning was not enough to save her.

[00:34:01]At trial in May of 2012 in Smith County, Cargill took the stand and offered a very different version of events.

[00:34:11]She claimed Walker had suffered a sudden seizure in her car and that the death was accidental and that she had panicked, burned the body, and fled because she was afraid of being blamed.

[00:34:23]The forensic pathologist on the case, Dr. Meredith Lan testified that the manner of death was asphixxiation consistent with homicidal violence, though the specific mechanism could not be determined because of the condition of the remains after the fire.

[00:34:40]The penalty phase revealed a pattern that went back years and involved Cargill's own family.

[00:34:47]Three of her four sons took the stand and testified that their mother had choked them, kicked them, and locked them in their rooms as punishment.

[00:34:56]Former husbands described long-term emotional and physical abuse. A forensic psychologist, Dr. Dr. Antwanet McGarahan evaluated Cargill and diagnosed borderline personality disorder with antisocial and narcissistic features, an IQ of 114, and what she called moderate psychopathic characteristics.

[00:35:19]The evaluation described Cargill as chronically angry, hostile, and highly impulsive. The jury convicted her of capital murder and sentenced her to death. Post conviction, Cargill's attorneys Brad Levenson and Derek Verhagen introduced an affidavit from epilepsy specialist Dr. Samden Lu supporting the possibility that Walker could have died of sudden unexpected death in epilepsy known as SUDEP.

[00:35:49]They requested a live evidentiary hearing. Smith County Judge Jack Sche Jr. declined to hold one. The prosecution responded that Cargill's conviction was based on overwhelming evidence, including DNA, as well as her own admissions.

[00:36:07]The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals rejected all 15 habius claims in 2017.

[00:36:14]The United States Supreme Court denied Seriar.

[00:36:18]Kimberly Cargill remains on death row at the Patrick L. OD Daniel unit in Gatesville. No execution date has been set. Cherry Walker was a vulnerable woman who trusted the wrong person with her time and her safety. She was killed on the same day she was asked to tell the truth in court, by the person who had the most to lose from that testimony.

[00:36:43]This next case also involves a woman whose guilt has never been seriously questioned by prosecutors. But the way she ended up on death row, the lawyer who failed to defend her and the country that tried to save her tell a very different story.

[00:36:59]Linda Cardi.

[00:37:01]On May 16th, 2001, four people forced their way into the Houston apartment of Joanna Rodriguez and her partner.

[00:37:10]Rodriguez, who was just 20 years old and her 4-day old baby boy were abducted.

[00:37:17]The infant was later found alive in one vehicle. Rodriguez was found suffocated in the trunk of another. The woman whose fingerprints were in both cars was Linda Cardi, and the story behind how she got there is one of the strangest and most legally troubled cases on this entire list. Cardi is a British citizen born on the island of St. Kits on October 5th, 1958 when it was still a British colony.

[00:37:46]She moved to the United States, settled in Texas, and in the 1980s worked as a confidential informant for the Drug Enforcement Administration. In the weeks leading up to the kidnapping, Cardi told several people, including her aranged husband, a neighbor named Florence Meyers, and a storage facility employee, that she was about to have a baby boy.

[00:38:10]She specified the date, May 16th. She gave this date to multiple people. She did not appear to be pregnant. During the home invasion, the victim's husband testified that one of the intruders answered a cell phone inside the apartment and told the person on the other end that they were inside.

[00:38:32]That detail paired with Card's fingerprints in both vehicles.

[00:38:36]Her false pregnancy claims timed to the exact day of the abduction and the testimony of her three co-defendants formed the foundation of the prosecution's case. The codefendants, Christopher Robinson, Gerald Anderson, and Carlos Williams all testified against Cardi in exchange for non- capital plea deals.

[00:39:00]Robinson was the state's primary witness and the most damaging. He later admitted under oath that prosecutors had explicitly threatened him with death row if he refused to cooperate and implicate Cardi. That admission, extraordinary as it was, did not result in legal relief for Cardi. The trial was handled by courtappointed attorney Jerry Garino, a lawyer whose record in capital cases was dismal by any standard.

[00:39:30]Garino had lost more than 20 capital cases over the course of his career, making him one of the least effective capital defense attorneys in the history of the Texas system.

[00:39:41]In Card's case, Garino failed to travel to St. Kits to interview her family, where she had been remembered as a beloved school teacher, Sunday school instructor, and youth choir leader.

[00:39:55]That kind of humanizing testimony, if presented during the penalty phase, might have been the difference between a death sentence and life in prison.

[00:40:06]It was never heard by the jury. Cardi was sentenced to death in February of 2002.

[00:40:12]Her direct appeal was denied by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals in April of 2004.

[00:40:19]The Fifth Circuit denied relief in 2009.

[00:40:23]The Supreme Court denied siierary in 2010 and again in 2018.

[00:40:31]The British government intervened twice.

[00:40:34]The United Kingdom Foreign Office filed two separate AMUS briefs objecting that Britain was never notified of Cart's arrest under the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations.

[00:40:46]That treaty requires host countries to inform nationals of their right to contact their consulate. In Card's case, no one told her she had that right, and no one told Britain she had been arrested.

[00:41:01]In 2009, in a recording played at a public clemency event in London's Trafalgar Square, Cardi said she was sorry if she sounded desperate, but that she was desperate and that the British people might be her last hope.

[00:41:17]Linda Cardi has maintained from the very beginning that she was framed by drug dealers as retaliation for her earlier work as a federal informant and that the kidnapping was orchestrated to destroy her through the legal system.

[00:41:32]Courts have not accepted that claim. A rare hearing was granted by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals after Robinson's recent, but no relief followed.

[00:41:43]She remains on death row. No execution date has been set. Her case has drawn sustained international attention, but within the Texas legal system, it has effectively reached a dead end. Linda Card's story is defined by what her lawyer failed to do. The next woman on this list had a lawyer who tried, but the damage had already been done long before the trial began.

[00:42:12]Erica Shepard.

[00:42:15]On June 30th, 1993, a Houston real estate agent named Marilyn Sage Merger came home to her apartment and left her front door open while she carried bags in from her car.

[00:42:28]She was 43 years old, a professional woman, and a mother of two.

[00:42:34]Those few seconds with the Dora jar were enough.

[00:42:38]19-year-old Erica Shepard and 19-year-old James Dickerson walked into the apartment.

[00:42:44]When Meger refused to surrender her car keys, Dickerson directed Shepherd to the kitchen to retrieve a butcher knife. She did.

[00:42:54]Dickerson stabbed Meer five times. One wound measured 5 and 1/2 in deep, severed the jugular vein, and lodged against the spine. He then bludgeoned her with a 10-b decorative statue while Shepherd held her down. Magger's body was found by her daughter covered with bed linens with a plastic dry cleaning bag placed over her head. It was a violent, chaotic, and deeply personal crime scene. The planning, such as it was, had taken shape the day before.

[00:43:29]A witness named Corey Jordan overheard Shepard and Dickerson discussing a carjacking.

[00:43:35]Shepard had described the type of victim she preferred. A skinny white woman walking between her car and her apartment with no children.

[00:43:45]That testimony combined with Shepherd's left finger and palm prints on the spare bedroom door of Mer's apartment and a confession she gave after being arrested in a Bay City motel room left little question about her role. James Dickerson was sentenced to death in May of 1994.

[00:44:05]He died of AIDS in prison on September 10th, 1999 before his execution could be carried out.

[00:44:13]Shepard was sentenced to death on March 3rd, 1995 in Harris County. She has now been on Texas death row for over 31 years, making her the longest serving woman in that system.

[00:44:28]Her case has become as much about what happened before the crime as what happened during it.

[00:44:34]Federal appellet judge Carolyn King later described Shepherd's life history as so horrific, so traumatic, and so marked by abuse that it could have persuaded a jury to spare her life.

[00:44:48]Shepherd had grown up in extreme poverty. She was a survivor of multiple sexual assaults. She had fled an abusive marriage just 27 days before the killing and had been turned away from a battered women's shelter when she sought help.

[00:45:04]Every safety net that existed in theory had failed her in practice. Her courtappointed lead attorney had never served as lead counsel on a capital case before and presented almost none of this background to the jury during the penalty phase.

[00:45:20]The 12 people who sentenced Erica Shepherd to death heard virtually nothing about who she was, what she had endured, or what circumstances had brought her to that apartment door.

[00:45:34]Federal habius filings later argued that the jury was improperly instructed on Texas's law of parties, which governs how accompllices can be held responsible for crimes committed by a codefendant.

[00:45:47]Federal judge Nancy Atlas agreed the instruction was erroneous, but she found that Shepherd had been an active participant in the crime, not merely a peripheral one, and denied relief. The Supreme Court denied Seriari in May of 2014 and again in May of 2021.

[00:46:08]In June of 2021, the Interamerican Commission on Human Rights granted precautionary measures urging the United States not to execute Shepard. That intervention carries moral weight, but no binding legal force within the American court system. Erica Shephard is now in her 50s. She has spent more than half her life on death row.

[00:46:32]No execution date has been set. A woman who had been failed by every system designed to protect her now sits in a cell in Gatesville, Texas, with no clear path to either freedom or execution.

[00:46:47]Her case is a study in what mitigation evidence can accomplish when it is presented to a jury and what happens when it is not. But the final case on this list goes beyond any failure of legal representation.

[00:47:01]It involves a woman who stood trial for her life and chose not to say a single word in her own defense.

[00:47:10]Tiffany Moss. In November of 2013, a man in Lawrenceville, Georgia, called police and told them something had happened to his daughter. When investigators arrived and began piecing together the scope of what they were dealing with, even veteran detectives struggled with what they found.

[00:47:31]The victim was Immani Moss, just 10 years old. She was Tiffany Moss' stepdaughter.

[00:47:38]Tiffany had married Emani's father, Emmon Moss, in July of 2009.

[00:47:44]The marriage gave Tiffany primary daily responsibility for the children in the household, while Emmen worked two jobs.

[00:47:52]Emani was not Tiffany's biological child. She was her stepchild. And in that distinction, prosecutors would argue, lay the root of everything that followed.

[00:48:04]Tiffany Moss had a prior conviction involving a Manny. In 2010, she had pleaded guilty under Georgia's first offender statute to child cruelty.

[00:48:16]Despite that conviction, the Georgia Division of Family and Children's Services returned Amani to the home.

[00:48:23]Multiple subsequent reports of abuse and neglect followed over the next 3 years.

[00:48:29]An anonymous tip in August of 2013 stated that Ammani appeared thin and was being neglected.

[00:48:37]DFCS screened that report out without investigation.

[00:48:42]Nobody followed up. Nobody visited the home. Nobody checked on Ammani.

[00:48:49]By the time Ammani's death came to light, the investigation revealed that what had happened to her was not sudden or accidental.

[00:48:57]Court filings described it as deliberate and sustained. Immani had been subjected to prolonged mistreatment and severe neglect over a period of weeks. The medical examiner, Dr. Michelle Stalenberg, testified that at the time of her death, Immani weighed 32 lb.

[00:49:17]That is roughly the weight of a toddler.

[00:49:19]She was 10 years old. What the investigation ultimately uncovered was staggering in scope.

[00:49:26]While Tiffany fed her two biological children normally, Ammani was found in deeply neglected conditions and had been denied adequate food for weeks.

[00:49:37]She had been confined and isolated from the rest of the household.

[00:49:41]After Emani died on or about October 28th, 2013, her parents attempted to destroy evidence and conceal what had happened.

[00:49:52]Emmen Moss eventually called police. He pleaded guilty in 2015 and is serving life without parole.

[00:50:00]Tiffany Moss's trial in April of 2019 before Judge George Hutchinson in Gwynette County was unlike any other capital case in recent Georgia history.

[00:50:12]against the urgent advice of standby council Brad Gardner and Emily Gilbert who told the court that Moss was incapable of effectively representing herself and that the jury would be left with nothing upon which to base a life sentence. Tiffany chose to represent herself.

[00:50:30]She made no opening statement. She did not cross-examine a single one of the state's witnesses. She presented no defense case of her own. She offered no closing argument. She sat in silence while the state made its case for her death. The jury of six men and six women returned guilty verdicts on all eight counts, including malice murder, felony murder, cruelty to children, and concealing a death in under 3 hours.

[00:51:02]The death sentence came after roughly 2 and a half hours of penalty phase deliberation.

[00:51:08]Gwinet County District Attorney Danny Porter called it a case without a happy ending.

[00:51:14]Deputy Chief Assistant DA Lisa Jones told jurors in her closing that Ammani had not been treated as a child in that household, that she had been treated as nothing, as a nuisance, as something disposable. Jones described the conditions of Ammani's final days as being alone, confined, and ignored, while life in the rest of the apartment continued as normal. After sentencing, Porter told reporters there is no joy when a jury imposes a death sentence, but that this was one of the worst cases he had ever seen. Tiffany Moss is the only woman on Georgia's death row. She is held at Arendelle State Prison. Her appellet litigation has focused on whether her decision to wave counsel was knowing and voluntary. Courts have rejected those claims. A 2024 order denied her competency challenges and upheld the sentence. Appeals continue.

[00:52:15]Immani's grandmother, Robin Moss, sued DFCS, alleging that case workers had ignored repeated warning signs over multiple years.

[00:52:25]The case contributed to reforms in the Georgia child welfare system. Reforms that came too late for the girl they were meant to protect.

[00:52:34]Immani Moss was 10 years old. She weighed 32 lb.

[00:52:39]Thanks for watching. Click here to see our next