Massachusetts 1969 Cold Case Solved — arrest shocks community

Added: 2026-06-01

[00:00:00]In 1969, the world was looking up. Two astronauts had just walked on the moon.

[00:00:05]Half a million people were screaming at Woodstock. America felt like it was standing on the edge of something new, something electric. But in the small town of Tukesbury, Massachusetts, life moved at a different speed. Tukesbury was the kind of place where nothing bad ever happened. Doors stayed unlocked.

[00:00:23]Kids played outside until dark. Everyone knew everyone's name. Parents didn't worry about where their children were because in Tukesbury, nothing bad ever happened. Until September 26th, 1969, when a 15-year-old boy named John McCabe borrowed his father's aftershave, walked out his front door, and stepped into a nightmare that would destroy his family for the next four decades. To understand what was lost that night, you have to understand who Jon was. Bill McCabe was an engineer. His wife Evelyn worked at the school library. They had three kids.

[00:00:57]Debbie, who was 17, John, who was 15, and little Roberta, who was just six.

[00:01:02]From the outside, they were the most ordinary family in the most ordinary town. But Jon was not ordinary. His sister Debbie still laughs about the day she opened her bedroom closet, and grasshoppers exploded out in every direction. Jon was standing around the corner watching, waiting for exactly that reaction. His sister, Roberta, says his hands were always dirty. Not because he was careless, because he was always building something, fixing something, figuring something out. He worshiped his father, the engineer. He spent hours in the garage with tools he barely knew how to use, taking apart broken things just to see how they worked. He loved animals the way only certain kids do. One afternoon, Evelyn heard the front door open. She turned around and Jon was standing in the doorway holding a full-grown injured Canadian goose. Just standing there holding a goose. Looking at her like this was perfectly reasonable. He was noise and life and mess. He was the kind of kid whose absence you would feel in every single room. On September 26th, 1969, John had one thing on his mind. There was a dance that Friday evening at the Nights of Columbus Hall, a school dance. Nothing extraordinary unless you were 15 years old and had been looking forward to it all week. John spent the entire afternoon getting ready. He took a shower. He fixed his hair until it was exactly right. He put on his nicest clothes, and then he walked to his father's cabinet, picked up the aftershave, and put it on. Even though he didn't have a single hair on his face to shave, he was 15. But tonight felt important. His mother, Evelyn, watched him walk out the front door. She had no idea she was watching him for the last time. The dance ended at 11 p.m. 11:00 came. She started watching the window.

[00:02:42]Midnight. No, John. Something moved inside her. that thing that lives in the chest of every parent and activates before the brain can catch up. She grabbed her keys. She drove to the school. She rolled down her window in the dark and screamed his name into the empty streets. John. John. Nothing answered. She drove every route she could think of. She checked every corner. Jon was a prankster. Yes, but he would never frighten his mother like this. Not for hours. Not without a word.

[00:03:10]She drove home. She got down on her knees and she prayed through the entire night.

[00:03:17]The next morning, September 27th, 1969, three young children were cutting through a vacant lot on Maple Street in Lel, just 5 miles from Chukesbury, just an empty piece of land near the railroad tracks. They found a body, a teenage boy, face down in the dirt. He was bound in a way that defied humanity, a calculated, cruel mechanism where his own movements would work against him.

[00:03:40]Duct tape ensured he couldn't call for help. He wasn't just killed. He was left there alone in the dark. And his own desperate need to survive did the rest.

[00:03:50]His name was John Joseph McCabe, 15 years old. Police came to the McCabe house that morning. They took Bill to the basement away from Evelyn to tell him what they had found. But Evelyn pressed herself to the bathroom floor and put her ear against the vent. She heard everything. She lay there on that cold floor and listened to the police tell her husband that their son was dead, that his eyes had been taped shut, that his mouth had been taped shut, that he had been tied up and left in a field like he was nothing. She didn't move.

[00:04:19]She just lay there and cried. Bill drove to the morg and identified the body of his 15-year-old son. He never talked about what that looked like. Some things a father cannot say out loud. Three police departments launched a joint investigation that same morning. They combed that vacant lot and bagged what little evidence 1969 technology could process. They worked to reconstruct J's final hours piece by piece. And very quickly, they knew one thing for certain. This was not random. Within days, investigators had their eyes locked on specific suspects. Teenagers from John's own town. They even had a description of the car that took him. So why did it take 43 years for handcuffs to finally click? Stay with me. Because the answer is one of the most maddening things you will ever hear. Two names were now in the police files. Michael Ferrer and Walter Shel. But in 1969, a name without proof was just a ghost. The investigators who combed that vacant lot on Maple Street walked away with physical evidence. Rope, duct tape, Jon's clothing, his shoes, and something else. Scrapings of an unidentified foreign material found directly on Jon's clothes. something that transferred onto him, possibly from a car seat, possibly from another person. In the modern era of forensics, that material might have cracked the case open in a week. Today, DNA and advanced chemistry speak for the dead. But in 1969, it went into a plastic bag, into a file, and sat there for decades without DNA technology, without computer databases that didn't exist yet. That foreign material was just a mystery inside a bigger mystery.

[00:05:59]Physical evidence existed, but evidence without the tools to read it is just noise. A witness came forward and told investigators they had seen a car parked near the vacant lot on the night Jon was murdered, a maroon 1965 Chevy Impala. At the same time, a separate tip led police to a 16-year-old named Michael Ferrer and his friend Nancy Williams. They had picked Jon up while he was hitchhiking on his way to the dance. Ferrer told police that after dropping Jon at the dance, he went to meet his best friend, a 17-year-old named Walter Shel, and the two of them took a drive to Lel to get some beer. In Walter Shel's car, a maroon 1965 Chevy Impala, the same make, the same model, the same color as the car, a witness had spotted near the crime scene. Police brought Walter Shel in for questioning. He denied everything. They asked him to take a polygraph, a lie detector test. He failed five times total. Walter Shelley sat in that chair and answered questions about the night John McCabe died. Five times the results came back the same.

[00:07:02]The examiner's conclusion was not ambiguous. Walter Shel was lying in all vital areas of the questioning. But a failed polygraph is not evidence. It cannot be used in court. It cannot get you an arrest warrant. Police searched Walter Shel's car. They went through every inch of that maroon Chevy Impala.

[00:07:22]Nothing. The car was clean. Michael Ferrer, meanwhile, was not making things easier for himself. While joy riding with friends, Ferrer said something that nobody in that car forgot. The conversation turned to John McCabe's murder. Everyone in Tokbury was talking about it. And Ferrer, in what he would later call a joke, said the words out loud. Yeah, I did it. He laughed. He said he was just being a joker. The police did not find it funny, but there was nothing they could do with it. No physical evidence, no witness placing him at the scene. Police had a witness car match, five failed polygraphs, a dark joke, and a gut feeling shared by every detective who touched the file.

[00:08:01]None of it was enough. And then in 1970, both Michael Ferrer and Walter Shel joined the armed forces and left Tukesbury. Just like that, gone. You can draw your own conclusions about the timing. The investigation had nowhere left to go. The case went cold. But for Bill and Evelyn McCabe, nothing went cold. Bill started writing. He filled notebooks with every story, every detail of the investigation, every name. He made over a thousand calls to police across 41 years. He would call in the middle of the night. Evelyn would wake up and find him on the phone at 2:00 a.m. still pushing, still refusing to let anyone forget. He was not trying to be difficult. He was a father who refused to let a police department file his son away. Evelyn's grief took a different shape. For years, she set a place for Jon at the dinner table every single night. His seat, his plate, his spot in the family. Because removing that place setting meant accepting something she was not willing to accept.

[00:09:02]She told an interviewer years later that her grief was so overwhelming, she would sit alone in the dark, trying to mentally imagine the exact fear her son felt in those final moments just to carry a piece of what he had to endure alone.

[00:09:15]That is not the behavior of someone who has moved on. That is a mother who never left that vacant lot. The two suspects police had always believed were responsible were gone. The case was frozen. But what the investigators didn't know, what no one knew yet was that there was a third shadow over this entire case. A third person who had been there that night who knew every detail that never made it into any newspaper.

[00:09:39]And that man didn't run. He quietly built himself a life, raised a family, and stayed close less than a few miles from the McCabe home for decades. While Bill made his thousand phone calls, while Evelyn set that empty place at the dinner table until 31 years after the murder, at a backyard cookout, everything changed. 31 years later, at a backyard cookout, a drunk man said something he should have kept to himself. But first, you need to understand one man. Jack Ward had grown up in Tukesbury. He knew John McCabe the way kids in small towns know each other.

[00:10:13]And after Jon was murdered, Jack stayed close to Bill McCabe the way good people do when a family falls apart. Over the years, Bill would pull Jack aside quietly. Jackie, if you ever hear anything about John, you let me know.

[00:10:27]Keep your ears open. Jack always said he would. But years passed, then decades, and Jack never heard anything until November of the year 2000. Picture a backyard cookout on a warm evening in Tukesbury. People from the old neighborhood catching up, eating, drinking. Michael Ferrer was there. By this point, he was pushing 50. He had moved to Salem, New Hampshire, married Nancy Williams, the same girl who had been in the car the night they gave Jon a ride to the dance. Jack Ward was also there. The afternoon passed. People ate, people drank, and then Michael Ferrer said something that stopped Jack Ward cold. He didn't whisper it. He didn't pull Jack aside. He just said it out loud like a confession that had been sitting behind his teeth for 31 years and finally pushed its way out. I know who killed John McCabe. Jack didn't respond right away. Ferrer said it again. I know who killed Jon. Jack finally asked who, Walter? Ferrer said Walter Shel. Because of Mara, a name, a motive, a reason why a 15-year-old boy ended up hog tied and alone in a vacant field. Jack sat with that information for the rest of the evening. His mind was moving fast because going to Bill McCabe with the wrong information after 31 years was not something Jack was willing to do. As he said later, "You go knocking on somebody's door and say, "Hey, I know who killed your son. You better have it right." But Jack did go because a promise is a promise. He sat Bill McCabe down and told him everything, every word. Bill's hands were shaking. He went and got his Bible.

[00:12:02]He opened it to the book of John, the Gospel of John, the very beginning, and he wrote the names down on that page.

[00:12:07]Walter Shelley, Michael Ferrer, and then he called the police. Now, here is where this story will make your blood boil.

[00:12:14]The police did not act on Bill's call.

[00:12:17]Not immediately, not for months. Not for years. Three full years passed. Three years of Bill calling. Three years of we're looking into it. A father had just handed investigators a potential confession straight from the mouth of one of their original suspects and the system took 3 years to follow up. Bill made his thousand calls and the phone just kept ringing. It was 2003 before police finally showed up at Michael Ferrer's door in Salem, New Hampshire.

[00:12:46]Ferrer was 50 years old. When investigators asked him about the cookout, he gave them a completely different story. He said Jack Ward was the one going around saying, "Shelly did it. Shel did it drunk, loud, repeating it all afternoon. And Ferrer said he finally got tired of hearing it. So he said, "Yeah, he probably did it just to shut Jack up." No recording, no other witnesses. Just Jack's version against Ferrer's version. Dead end again. But buried inside Ferrer's 2003 account of that night in 1969, almost as an afterthought, something new appeared. A name that had never shown up in any file before. Ferrer had always said it was just him and Walter Shel that night. But now in 2003, he quietly added a third person to the story, a name Edward Allen Brown. Investigators noted it, filed it, and the case went cold again. Four years later, in January 2007, a new Middle Sex County District Attorney named Jerry Leon was sworn into office. Within weeks, the L police brought him the McCabe file. Leon went through everything and when he reached the 2003 interview, that name caught his eye immediately. Edward Allan Brown, 17 years old in 1969, lived close to the McCabe house. Never interviewed, never questioned, never in a single police report from the original investigation.

[00:14:10]Leone flagged it. But before a proper cold case approach could be built around Brown, the paperwork stalled. Resources shifted. For four more years, the name Edward Allen Brown sat in that file, unnoticed, unchecked, untouched, until 2011, 42 years after the murder when a detective named Linda Coughlin was handed the file. She didn't just read Brown's name, she tracked him down to London Dair, New Hampshire, walked up to his porch, knocked on the door. Brown answered. And when Detective Coughlin asked him what he knew about the murder of John McCabe, Edward Allen Brown looked her directly in the eye and said he had never even heard of John McCabe in a town the size of Tukesbury where Jon's death had shaken every household where hundreds had come to his funeral.

[00:14:54]This man claimed he had never even heard the name. Coughlin left his porch knowing he was lying. But she didn't have leverage. Not yet. She didn't have to wait long. Hours later, her phone rang. It was Carolyn Brown, Edward's wife. She told Detective Coughlin that her husband was lying. That decades earlier, Edward had come to her and confessed he had been involved in the murder of a young boy. She had carried that secret for over 20 years. And now, watching him lie to a detective at their own front door. She had picked up the phone. His own wife had turned him in.

[00:15:26]After 42 years, the wall was finally cracking. But a wife's account of a decades old conversation was still not enough for an arrest. The case was not solved yet. Stay with me because what happened the next time Detective Coughlin pulled Edward Allen Brown into that interrogation room is the moment this 41-year silence completely shattered. Every case on this channel takes days of research, fact-checking, and digging through real records to uncover the truth behind lives that should never be forgotten. If you support what we do, please like, subscribe, and share your thoughts in the comments. Your support helps us continue bringing these solved cold cases to light. Now, let's get back to the case. In 2011, a detective walked into a room with Edward Allen Brown. She walked out with the truth. Evelyn McCabe had watched investigators come and go for four decades. New faces, same promises, same dead ends. But when Detective Coughlin brought Brown back in, she did something different. She put Caroline's statement on the table. His own wife. 20 years of silence broken with a single phone call. Something shifted in Brown's face. The practiced stillness of a man who had spent years deciding he would never talk started to crack. His breathing changed. His eyes dropped to the floor. Coughlin asked him to take a polygraph. He agreed. He failed. Every single question, every single area. The game was over. His wife had broken the pact. The polygraph had confirmed what everyone already knew. It was time to talk. But Brah was not going to talk for free. He had one condition, one word. Immunity. No prison time. No conviction. full cooperation in exchange for walking away clean after being present at the murder of a 15-year-old boy and saying nothing for 41 years.

[00:17:11]Here is the part that should make you uncomfortable. The state said, "Yes."

[00:17:15]Prosecutors made the deal because they had no choice. Without Brown, they had two suspects and zero eyewitnesses. The only way to crack open 43 years of silence was a man who had been in that car, on that road, in that field, and could describe exactly what happened in the kind of detail that only the person who was there would know. So, the state traded one man's freedom to chase two others. Justice sometimes comes at a price that doesn't feel like justice.

[00:17:40]And then Edward Alan Brown started talking. He said it started at 10:30 p.m. on the night of September 26th, 1969. Walter Shelley and Michael Ferrer pulled up outside his house. Brown was home watching television. They told him they needed his help. Help with what? He didn't find out until he was already in the car. As Walter Shel drove toward the Knights of Columbus Hall, Ferrer explained the plan. There was a boy at that dance, a boy who Walter believed had been flirting with his girlfriend.

[00:18:07]They were going to find him and teach him a lesson. That was the word they used, lesson. Brown said he didn't get out of the car at first. He told himself this was nothing serious. And then Ferrer spotted John McCabe on the side of the road. Thumb out. Hitchhiking home. There he is. Shelley pulled over.

[00:18:25]Ferrer got out of the front passenger seat, grabbed Jon by the arm, and shoved him into the back seat next to Brown.

[00:18:32]Jon was 15 years old, and three older boys had just pulled him into a car in the dark. Ferrer twisted around from the front seat and started hitting him. Jon put his arms up trying to block the blows. He was scared. Brown could see that clearly. They drove under the Spaghettiville Bridge. They turned up a dirt road. They pulled into the vacant lot on Maple Street in Lel. Brown pushed Jon out of the car. He would say later that he thought they were just going to rough him up, scare him, send him home shaken. He was wrong. What Brown confirmed next is what no newspaper had ever printed, what no police report had ever released, what only someone who was standing in that field could possibly know. He described the exact cruel restraint method used on Jon. Details that had never been shared with the public, proving beyond a shadow of a doubt that he was standing in that field. He described the words they said over Jon before they walked away. This will teach you to mess with Mara. And they walked back to the car and they drove away. They drove around for a while drinking beer, not talking about what they had left behind. It was Brown who finally said it. They should go back. They should untie him. They turned the car around. When they got back to the lot, Shelley and Ferrer got out.

[00:19:44]Brown stayed in the car. He watched them walk across the dark field. They were gone for 30 seconds, maybe 45. They came back fast. One of them said it quietly.

[00:19:54]He's not breathing. John McCabe had died alone in that field in the dark trying to free himself. He was 15 years old.

[00:20:01]They drove Brown home. He went upstairs.

[00:20:03]He sat in the dark. He thinks he cried.

[00:20:06]For 41 years, Edward Allen Brown said nothing because Michael Ferrer had made one thing very clear before they went their separate ways that night. If anybody talks about this, I'll kill them. Brown believed him. On April 15th, 2011, nearly 42 years after J's body was found, police arrested all three men, Edward Alan Brown, for manslaughter, Walter Shelley, and Michael Ferrer for first-degree murder. Lowel police brought the Mabe family in and told them what Brown had said. Bill McCabe heard it and collapsed. He keeled over the table sobbing. And then Evelyn said something quietly that the room never forgot. The murderers came to the wake and they came to the funeral. After 42 years, the truth was finally out. But here is what nobody tells you about the truth. The truth alone does not put anyone in prison. Getting a confession is one thing. Proving it to 12 strangers in a courtroom is something else entirely. And what was about to happen in that courtroom would break a family in ways even four decades of waiting had not managed to do. The same evidence, the same witness, the same story. And yet, one man walked free. January 2013, Lel Superior Court. 43 years of waiting had come down to this room, this jury, these 12 strangers. Bill McCabe was 85 years old. His body was failing. The stress of four decades had left marks that doctors could measure. He was too fragile to sit in that courtroom, but he had made sure his voice would be heard.

[00:21:38]Before the trial began, Bill had recorded an official video deposition, a formal statement captured on camera for the court to use when the time came.

[00:21:47]When that recording played in the courtroom, the room went completely still. The prosecutor had asked him one question. How old was Jon at that day?

[00:21:56]And Bill McCabe answered the way only a father counts the days of a child he lost too soon. He was 15 years 6 months and 2 weeks. Not 15, not approximately 15. 15 years, 6 months, and 2 weeks.

[00:22:11]Because Bill McCabe had been counting every single one of those days for 43 years. The prosecution's case rested almost entirely on Edward Allen Brown.

[00:22:20]He took the stand and walked the jury through everything. The phone call, the car, the road to Lel, the vacant field.

[00:22:28]It was the most detailed firsthand account of John McCabe's final hours that had ever been spoken out loud in a public setting. The defense had one job: destroy Edward Allen Brown completely, and they did it without mercy. Defense attorney Eric Wilson went after Brown for two full days on cross-examination.

[00:22:46]He didn't just question Brown's memory, he systematically dismantled his credibility piece by piece in front of the jury. The central argument was surgical. Brown had not walked into a police station with a guilty conscience.

[00:22:58]He had been interrogated by trained detectives, failed a polygraph, been threatened with spending the rest of his life in prison, and then offered a deal, no jail time, if he told prosecutors what they wanted to hear, and then came the moment the prosecution dreaded.

[00:23:14]Wilson asked Brown directly, "Had investigators told him the crime scene was a dirt lot?" "Yes, near a railroad tower." "Yes." that Shelley was jealous over Mara Shiner. Yes. Brown admitted under oath that pieces of his story had come from the investigators themselves.

[00:23:30]But here is what the defense could not explain away. Brown had described the specific binding method, the exact way the rope connected the ankles to the neck. Details that had never been in any newspaper. Details kept strictly inside the investigation files for 43 years.

[00:23:48]Brown knew things that only someone who was there could know. The defense called it coached. The prosecution called it proof. The jury would have to decide.

[00:23:56]But before the jury decided anything, the defense called one more witness. Her name was Mara Shiner. She was the girl.

[00:24:03]The 13-year-old Walter Shel had supposedly been so jealous of her that he was willing to kill a 15-year-old boy. She took the stand and told the jury that John McCabe had never flirted with her, never shown any interest. And then she said something that landed like a grenade in the prosecution's case. She was not dating Walter Shelley at the time of the murder. They started dating after Jon died. But here is what the police record showed. Mara had told investigators years earlier that she and Walter had been together since she was 12 years old. Now on the witness stand, she couldn't remember saying that. J's sister, Roberta, said exactly what most people in that courtroom were thinking.

[00:24:41]Why lie about dating someone unless it was because of her that Jon was murdered? When the prosecutor asked Mara directly, "Was Walter Shel a jealous man?" She didn't hesitate. Absolutely.

[00:24:53]There was one more legal reality sitting in that courtroom that nobody in the public gallery fully understood. The jury had two choices. First-degree murder or seconddegree murder. That was it. Manslaughter. The charge that might have fit the prosecution's own version of events, was not an option. The statute of limitations on manslaughter had run out decades ago. Massachusetts law put a six-year limit on that charge.

[00:25:18]It had expired long before any arrest was ever made. One juror, Michael Duket, later told reporters what had happened inside that deliberation room. He had believed Brown. He had believed Ferrer was there. He had wanted to convict him of something, but he wanted manslaughter. And manslaughter wasn't on the table. The jury came back, not guilty. Bill McKay was not in the courtroom. He was in a room down the hall, too sick, too scared of what he might hear. Evelyn had to be the one to walk to that room and tell him. She said later she was terrified to open that door. I was afraid he was going to die.

[00:25:53]She told him, and Bill McCay broke down completely. 4 days later, his heart gave out. His family called it what it was, a father who had nothing left to fight for and nothing left to hope for. They buried Bill McCabe next to his son, John. Father and son together at last.

[00:26:10]Separated by 43 years of an open wound that never closed. Evelyn stood at Bill's grave and made him a promise. She told him she would take over. She told him she wasn't done. Michael Ferrer walked out of that courtroom a free man.

[00:26:22]He remains free today. But the story was not over. Because Walter Shel had not gone to trial yet. And Evelyn McCabe had made a promise to a dead man. Bill McCabe died without justice. But somewhere in that grief, his wife found something harder than grief. She found fury. 7 months later, the same case walked into the same courtroom. This time, justice showed up. September 2013, Lel Superior Court. Michael Ferrer was free. Bill McCabe was in the ground. And Evelyn McCabe, 80 years old, widowed, exhausted from four decades of fighting, was still standing. Walter Shelley walked into that courtroom as a 61-year-old man. remarried, settled. He had lived quietly in Tukesbury for 43 years, just a few miles from the house where Bill and Evelyn had spent every one of those years wondering who killed their son. He had been 17 years old on the night of September 26th, 1969. He was the one who drove the car. He was the one whose jealousy had set everything in motion. Now he sat at a defense table and waited for 12 strangers to decide what that was worth.

[00:27:29]Robera McCabe, John's little sister, who had been just 6 years old the night her brother didn't come home, sat in that courtroom for every single day of the trial. She said later that sitting through it the second time was harder than the first. Dad wasn't there for backup. Evelyn could not bring herself to go inside. She sat outside the courtroom and waited the same way she had waited by the window on the night of September 26th, 1969. Her daughter Debbie said Evelyn was scared she would drop dead right there in the hallway if she heard another not guilty. So she waited outside and she prayed. The prosecution had learned from its mistakes. In the Ferrer trial, Brown had crumbled under cross-examination. This time, prosecutors built their entire case around the one thing the defense could never fully explain. What Brown knew that he shouldn't have known. Brown took the stand again and this time he was different, calmer, more direct. When the defense came after him with the same arguments from seven months earlier, he held his ground. He pointed at Walter Shel and described exactly what Shel had done in that field. The drive, the road, the rope. The words spoken over a 15-year-old boy lying face down in the dirt. The defense argued everything they had argued before. Brown was unreliable.

[00:28:44]Brown had a deal. Brown had reasons to lie. But this jury listened differently.

[00:28:49]The deliberations lasted two days.

[00:28:51]Evelyn sat outside. Roberta sat inside and held her breath. And then the jury came back. The room went completely silent. Guilty. Walter Shel's knees buckled when he heard it. The man who had driven that car, who had lived freely for 43 years while a family fell apart. His legs gave out beneath him at the sound of a single word. Someone ran outside to tell Evelyn. Robera McCabe sat in that courtroom and thought about Bill, about the notebooks, about the thousand phone calls, about the Bible with the names written in the book of John. "I thought my father would be proud," she said. "We got one of them."

[00:29:28]Walter Shel was sentenced to life in prison on February 20th, 2014. But here is the part that never makes it into the headline. Walter Shel was 17 years old when he murdered John McCabe. He spent his teens, his 20s, his 30s, his 40s, his 50s, all of it as a free man. He raised a family. He lived a life. The prison sentence he received in 2014 is real. But the decades he spent free while the McCabe suffered every single day cannot be given back. In 2016, a judge reduced his conviction from first-degree murder to seconddegree murder because Walter Shel was a juvenile when he committed the crime and the law had changed regarding mandatory sentences for juveniles. He is now eligible for parole in 2029 when he will be 79 years old. John McCabe's family has vowed to oppose every single parole request he ever makes. Also in 2016, Evelyn McCabe passed away. She died knowing that one of the men responsible for her son's death was in prison. She died knowing that another walked free.

[00:30:30]She died with a wrongful death civil lawsuit still pending, a case her daughters, Robera and Debbie continued fighting on her behalf. She never stopped. Michael Ferrer, acquitted of murder, untouchable on that charge forever, eventually pleaded guilty to perjury in 2021 for lying under oath to a grand jury in 2008 for covering up a murder for over 40 years. His punishment, 5 years of probation. He did not spend a single day in prison. Edward Alan Brown also walks free today. Three men were in that field on the night of September 26th, 1969. One is in prison.

[00:31:07]Two are free. Before Evelyn died, she went to the cemetery. She stood at the graves of her husband and her son, Bill and John McCabe, buried side by side, and she spoke to them both. John, guess what? We got him. She looked at Bill's grave. Billy, it turned out beautifully.

[00:31:26]Please, John, take great care of him till I get there, and then I will. In 1969, a 15-year-old boy borrowed his father's aftershave, walked out his front door, and put his thumb out on the side of a road. He was trying to get to a dance. He never made it home. Bill McCabe spent 43 years writing his son's story. He filled notebooks with every memory, every name, every dead end. He made a thousand phone calls. He refused to let anyone forget. But Bill never got to write the ending. Someone else had to write it for him. And the ending when it finally came after 43 years, after two trials, after a father died of a broken heart and a mother made promises at grave sites was not the clean, complete justice that stories are supposed to end with. It was one conviction out of three. One man in prison out of three who were there. One family left with the knowledge of exactly what happened to their son and the permanent understanding that knowing the truth and getting justice are not always the same thing. John Joseph McCabe was 15 years old, 6 months and 2 weeks when he died.

[00:32:31]He will be 15 years old, 6 months, and 2 weeks forever. And his father, who wrote every chapter of his life, never got to write the last one. But he never stopped trying. Neither did John. Walter Shel becomes eligible for parole in 2029. As someone who has heard this entire story, what would you decide if you were on that parole board? Leave your thoughts below. If Edward Allen Brown had never slipped that name into the 2003 interview, do you think this case ever gets solved? The answer might surprise you. One jury convicted Walter Shelley.

[00:33:03]Another jury acquitted Michael Ferrer.

[00:33:05]Same evidence, same witness, same story.

[00:33:09]What does that tell you about the justice system and about what justice actually means?