Ayin Bais

Ajouté : 2026-05-31

[00:00:02]The end of the sug now it takes him three to finish this topic because that's everything is torn open into little teeny tiny pieces. So we did since pic bay since pic bay doing two years and um the last class was Sunday night right last time we didn't have a class we read the beginning of the end of hey and the beginning of mv about the juosition the comparison the contrast between and which is right which we're going to talk about later on Then the Reb makes a statement.

[00:00:45]The whole concept of is for no.

[00:00:51]Now the truth is you should immediately surmise take out of that statement another statement which is that could exist even and you can question that. I think it's a legitimate question but that question we're going to leave for a different time.

[00:01:12]But the Reb makes a statement it ain't safe that used to go into even if you holding the sheet of for the creation it goes back to what with Russian till the Madre get the if there would be no be no and he starts to speak number one malus page kuf Five lines from the top of the page. For example, they can only be if there's a nation.

[00:02:11]It says and it's very hard to find the source of this. The first source is not there cannot be a king without subjects.

[00:02:24]Right?

[00:02:27]and the reason desire to create world is wants to be a king.

[00:02:37]There can't be a king without subject.

[00:02:39]Therefore entered into right this is basic stuff. Now this is a simple but also very very deep conversation. It's a very very deep conversation.

[00:02:56]Um, >> couldn't do it without without making to have available. It can't be any other way, right?

[00:03:13]>> I wouldn't mind answering that question.

[00:03:14]I'm just read the next question after it. So, I'm not going to answer it.

[00:03:44]What's the uniqueness of malus?

[00:03:48]What's the uniqueness of all the other >> huh?

[00:03:55]>> It's an answer. It's not the right answer for tonight. It's the right answer for tomorrow night.

[00:04:00]>> Who when >> doesn't it's not for itself is a whole different conversation >> on top.

[00:04:10]The alterba in jail had to defend how come is the lowest of the 10 spheres and you just put it on the top and you solve the whole problem.

[00:04:21]>> It's only if there's something >> that malus >> is a mido based on distance.

[00:04:30]Malus is an emotion based to say it's in perfect on farness.

[00:04:38]It's a per it's you gota admit it's based on farness.

[00:04:43]What a great that's a great noun.

[00:04:46]There's a pises.

[00:04:50]>> Um what's the concept? The concept means if you're too close to somebody, you can't be their king.

[00:04:59]Because if you're close to somebody, there's an er there's a relativism.

[00:05:02]There's a proximity. There's a certain measure of distance between you and them. He can't be the king. The classic example is if a man has a thousand children, he can't be their king. He can only be their father because they're his children. And it's not just cuz he likes them and whatever it is. It's because they're like him.

[00:05:19]They're close to him in their character.

[00:05:21]They're close to him and they're mad.

[00:05:22]They're close to him and their intelligence. They're sensitive to his kids.

[00:05:27]You can't be a king over Sodom, over ministers. You can't be a king over people who are very smart. There needs to be the Hebrew word, right? In English is translated as exaltedness. No one has any idea what the exaltedness means, which is why it's a perfect word to use. Exalted. Once they exalted an hour in his battle, everyone is exalted by exaltedness. Um, removal.

[00:05:54]The irony of course is there's another coin which is you can't be king over animals.

[00:06:01]You can control animals. You can dominate animals but you cannot be a king over animals. Why? Cuz animals you don't have a relationship with. Animals are not close to you. Animals you use now the animals may be using you also but that's the the limitation of the reg. I'm using you. You're using me. To use a Hebrew word an animal you can be a moh a shalot. You can rule them you can control them. You can corral them. You can herd them. You can use them, they could use you, but you can't have a connection.

[00:06:37]A meal is a very unusual mid. You know how unusual is he said indirectly that so often talk about they don't even speak about I would say that 70% of the time they only translate mus as an action.

[00:06:53]They don't talk about the emotion. The only time that the immediate emotion comes up is when it comes to rash cuz the whole rash is but otherwise it's it's you know I didn't that's not true there are seven midas but all the other midas like it says on page in the end of the first paragraph four lines from the end visi Most midas are based on a closeness is based on a distance. So what's the irony? What's the paradox? What's the what is the what are the two sides? What is the dichotomy? The two opposites that exist in mountains.

[00:07:48]>> It's dependent on someone else >> and it's dependent on It's based on distance >> and it's a real relationship.

[00:07:59]It's based on distance and it's a real relationship. That's true.

[00:08:04]>> That's why when it says they give two translations to the word, right? You have coals. When the coals are very hot, they call whispering coals. They glow, right? They glean. They glimmer. They to produce this light, right? Then the coals start to die. When they start to die, they get weaker. Then they call It means weak.

[00:08:35]You can only have a king if his subjects are in relationship with the king weak cuz they're strong even if the king is smarter than them. But they're smart.

[00:08:44]The king is smarter. That's not it's not they have to be far away. But at the same time, right close, you cannot be a king over subject of over animals. So you have to be misb in the concept.

[00:09:08]You have to be misb in the concept. We all know the classic martial of a king, right? The essence of mala, the essence of melo, the magic of the pimus of mala.

[00:09:20]That's maluka's last name. Tomorrow I'll tell you a different one. Mal's last name is the magic of Mal is and on both ends.

[00:09:32]The people want the king to be their king and the king is being their king by choice, by will, right? What's a king? Smart guy. Very smart. You know how smart he is? He wants to be left alone. That's how smart he is. You know how smart he is? He has he has enough to understand he should mix other people's business certainly not in other people's politics just for sake and no comments please wrote the letter it printed now they found it now they printed his safe they found it now after all these years wrote the letter and he says to the you don't want to be a don't be a but you're an sobb writes back to him that you wrote to me that I'm an adim I'm I know but I don't know if it's if you know what's going on here that writes in other words the politics is the childishness going on here so that I'm not looking to get myself into more trouble than I'm in he wrote to theb that even if theb doesn't want to be a but he's a son you know what's going on here you understand yourself I'm not looking for more trouble I'm good I got life I got what to But in that letter theb reveals there's not a lot of letters in the like that this letter was exposed in the last 10 15 years as far as I know what's going on around meb says a king is smart enough that's not a child that's not we're not discussing ing it. You don't understand that will speak only um or say it um a a person who's smart enough to know I don't want to leave but he has all the of leadership. So the people come to him and they say please be our king. What is the answer?

[00:11:43]I remember I was a kid had a teacher who was really mad of me I'm talking 30 40 50 years after I was in his class his name was fash was a big lu gorgeous Jew had so much it was disgusting so when the s came out so his was not ped I don't know I don't even know if if his picture is in there.

[00:12:15]So I met him and I asked him I said the conditionb came he's the first a lot of I said to him why he said because anybody went over to theb and asked theb to the used to say and everybody knew that he meant the p didn't want to make trouble and the was stubborn about it there was very few people theas There were certain the um the kids, you know, the posers. Okay.

[00:12:53]But a lot of I I I my my was has a picture. He wouldn't give it to I didn't put it into the book. I said, "Why don't you give him the picture?" He says was not my I didn't want to fool anybody's personality the first >> but of course he came and he put on big shabas used to put on he wore bakl a blue jacket and a blue hat he used to put on >> huh before he would go and put on a black pants black jacket he put on he would change from head to toe to go to the kupus he put in big shows nobody in lab does When the deba went to a of any member of an he put in his kaput but he didn't just change his kapot he changed his pants cuz he wore colored pants he changed his kap his hat and change his tie used to prepare himself you see the pictures but he used to say you know passes away everybody's coming to the to be and the says He wants I'm not interested. What was the answer?

[00:14:14]Indeed.

[00:14:17]We want you. Why? Because you don't want t because you don't want. Now, of course, the the way the story should be told, of course, this is me telling you, I'm sure it should be told. Not only was I not born, my father was 11 when this happened.

[00:14:34]Yeah. 12 years old.

[00:14:37]This is an example where changed the Reb's mind. The Reb said no said yes.

[00:14:42]The Reb said no said yes. The Reb said no said yes. The Reb said no said yes.

[00:14:47]The Reb said okay what happened the and he suffered so much for it couldn't say a word.

[00:15:01]Yeah. But the essence of mala is the people come to the king and say please be our king. And the way it's described in how do you make someone into a king?

[00:15:10]You lay down flat like a like a carpet.

[00:15:13]They should step ALL OVER YOU.

[00:15:16]COMPLETE THIS BATTLE.

[00:15:18]That's the inside of the and then the which is why when a mel agrees to be the mel of the how much I talk about this all THE TIME. HOW MUCH OF HIMSELF DOES THE KING GIVE THE PEOPLE THE WHOLE SELF LIKE THE SAID MY FATHER BELONGS to it's so interesting it theim asked theb to be and when theb agrees he keeps himself nothing and the relationship is all distance you see the irony it's a it's a connection But it's a connection based on the fact that the king and the far away and then you say the king becomes bigger when he's farther away. So the the way you describe it in practical terms is when you're close to another person, you compete with that person.

[00:16:21]When you're far from another person, you don't compete with the person. When you're really far from another person, you have a sense of responsibility for that person. It's not about but about if you are much higher than other people, you're drawn to feel for them.

[00:16:42]If you're a little bit high person, you're afraid that person's going to take you over. So this competition and jealousy, but if you're very far from everybody else, when you're really far from other people, you're drawn to get involved with other people.

[00:16:58]That's malus. So malus is a real connection. You know the that there's no element. It's not a game. There's a real connection between which is so interesting and so incomprehensible.

[00:17:13]It's English used to say hills.

[00:17:29]You know my understanding of compared to a cat, but if you're going to compare me and a BILL WITH THE SAME cat and yet there's a I don't know if I want to use the word is a real bonding. So the definition of is a relationship based on distance.

[00:17:54]So mean not just a world because doesn't only mean he's to a world means to a world that's da far away far away in other words does not allow forem to be a melik it allows him to be a it allows him to be a if the is going to be a mel you're going to have to have worlds which are that they're far away from the and the of which is distant.

[00:18:32]I I love to say this because I don't think this gets enough press in the in the in the machine of the wrote right which we're learning today. We finish correct has a beautiful and then two lines on top of Huh. So you have two lines to explain a little bit now what's the discussion and where's the is asking a question a what's the question b where's the answer just want to understand >> huh >> question just wants to understand >> he want what's there to understand what's wrong with what's the problem but what is not simple about doesn't say that. What's the tenets? The tenants is if there's a higher the lower is a lie. That's the if besides there is nothing. So it's just not true.

[00:20:07]If if what's means I don't exist.

[00:20:15]means I do exist but there's a union between him and me because he controls me and I give myself to him right after simple huh because it doesn't say but doesn't say added it yeah whoever edited it says is written we incorporate it into we make it into two yeah why do you have to have a law so the push to is that if you're holy if you're not a holy then you're holy at least yeah but the seventh is it is pain the beginning of paid Exactly the answer. I'm sorry.

[00:21:14]>> He doesn't answer the question.

[00:21:15]>> He does.

[00:21:16]>> You know what I'm saying? The first thing you said that does not answer the question.

[00:21:19]>> The what?

[00:21:21]>> What's the question?

[00:21:22]>> No. What's the answer?

[00:21:24]>> The answer you just said.

[00:21:25]>> Yeah. Why not?

[00:21:26]>> Because we don't we don't get something.

[00:21:28]It's just it's a fact. So >> you're right. It's a fact. But I'm not holding by that fact.

[00:21:34]>> That fact is the fact.

[00:21:35]>> Okay. So >> So in other words, I shouldn't I should be fry.

[00:21:39]>> That's all I'm saying. I'm just saying.

[00:21:41]>> But that's what I'm saying.

[00:21:43]That's a ter.

[00:21:45]>> It's a good >> It's a good opportunity. It's a good option. Yeah.

[00:21:48]>> But being fry is so depressing. Oh, it's depressing.

[00:22:02]everything else. Spend your life eating candy. It's fun when you're four and five and six.

[00:22:10]Wait, but Hashem wants to be a king and you can't be king unless you have subjects. In other words, Hashem cannot be a king unless we're yesesh.

[00:22:27]So created and he made us in a way that we should dk not be we should be a and the degree of our should be only and not why because this is where is our meal or to say it in other words if you look in the first piece of you'll see I'm telling you that I've been saying let's say you're in and you're in And yeah, and you want to be a sames.

[00:23:10]You want to have a connection to Hashem where you're his and he's your meal. You know what you got to do?

[00:23:19]You have to step away from B and become a yesesh. So that you could be an and they have to go away for that.

[00:23:36]I'm just reading a book called I finished with the pner and I put it away. I actually took it out of my bedroom because I was rereading the same lines every day. And back there so there's a story couldn't walk and walked and he said no I can walk the man was paralyzed let him step away'll be able to walk and there's actually a story that he needed a safety wouldn't bring it to him So he sang niggan and he got out of his chair.

[00:24:20]Ab was paralyzed, pulled over a ladder, climbed up the ladder, grabbed the safer, sat back down in his seat.

[00:24:30]So has a challenge.

[00:24:36]I have to be his for me to be his I have to make from myself. Yes.

[00:24:42]The story you know when he met he said he say how can you say later don't even understand the question he was seven what's if I don't exist how could I love the beginning of seven was seven born there's a whole cl about this it's not so partial The should tell this story. The told this met other words you say included in that is me. If I don't exist, there's no possibility forem.

[00:25:36]So you go down here the you go down from to buy after not before because you start you step down from Hashem wants to be our king. What are the requirements of him being a king?

[00:26:00]Number one >> far away. Number two >> relation. a real relationship with us with us. This is no.

[00:26:12]So the says So when it comes to the takes in five lines because it's so obvious he argues that there's no people there's no world there's no let's finish the but for those who lost the place it's on page hey seven lines from the top near the number 36 what about the fact that it says before the world was created right and by By the way, just for the record, this is special for you. Who wrote a denom?

[00:26:58]>> When did he live? Where did he live?

[00:26:59]What was he doing for a living? Who wrote a dum?

[00:27:04]>> Is it in the Is it where start?

[00:27:08]>> Huh?

[00:27:11]>> Whatever you do, guess Mark.

[00:27:13]>> No. No. It's a bad Don't guess. If you know, you know. You don't. No.

[00:27:18]>> No.

[00:27:20]>> Maybe.

[00:27:21]>> I don't know. Nobody knows. There's all kinds of speculations.

[00:27:25]>> Oh, we don't know really >> from the say if it was written after the time of the right. The last god was a high god. He he passed away in 1038 when he passed away the yeshiva of the closed and bubble closed and the big yeshiva since opened this was in Germany and you had the William and North Africa and in Spain any which was written say the same like for example like but any which was written after the time of the the fall of everybody says so goes back to but nobody is gorgeous it's not a really it's his that's what it is it's meditation on God. It's a music >> because it appears >> it appears on the mean >> and says that the was the king before he made the world we just said there's no people say so he answers Sure.

[00:29:07]Even the of connection to another. You know how complete Hashem is? He includes in his completion even the possibility of there being other having relationship with him. And therefore, Hashem as he is alone has the >> doesn't make more sense.

[00:29:26]>> Huh?

[00:29:28]If you would say and pull out the part, you wouldn't have it unless you first pull out the pardon.

[00:29:37]>> We're talking about the mid.

[00:29:39]>> I understand >> the mid exists. The possibility exists, the prospect exists.

[00:29:46]>> Okay. What are you saying?

[00:29:50]But there's no actual there's no that should be in a way of revealed light.

[00:30:03]If there's no world, it can't be conversation over. Full stop. Malus requires an it's a it's an undeniable law.

[00:30:14]The first example of the point that was made in the sh that we learned on Sunday that even if you say that and it goes back to it would not exist if there was no worlds case closed questions or comments but it's kind of causing issues here >> what's the issue >> they did you could have is as opposed to as when you take away from the aim is not a meal.

[00:30:52]It's a malik is not a meal. It's a mal.

[00:30:59]Let me ask you a question.

[00:31:03]I haven't said your name in a while, so I have to say it.

[00:31:07]How far ahead could you plan?

[00:31:13]I don't know but a little bit. Yeah, some people can plan along further ahead because it's very smart and very organizing. They can everybody's planning horizon is different. How?

[00:31:27]Yeah. Nobody can plan their whole life.

[00:31:32]Not only can't plan your whole life because you don't know what's going to happen. You can't plan your life because you can't think that far into the future.

[00:31:39]Correct? So you would agree that most of us can plan till a certain extent. Yeah.

[00:31:43]Some people can plan a week ahead. Some people plan a day ahead. Some people can plan even a year ahead. But you can't plan 20 years ahead. It's it's it's there's a lot of reasons why. And one of them is because your brain is not that big.

[00:31:57]>> No, you could. It just it just it's it's not real. It's not real. It's fake.

[00:32:01]>> No other. It's not a plan. No.

[00:32:03]>> Imagine you were extremely smart.

[00:32:06]smart like you know how smart was >> he told a plan to defeat David sent into camp spies with one goal one goal one goal >> that he should listen that's it and knew that if They follow he will get killed.

[00:32:39]>> Probably that's that's pretty that's pretty smart.

[00:32:42]>> Of course it's smart. So he sent in camp one goal. Don't help fight. Don't kill.

[00:32:50]Don't make anything. Just put a doubt in mind about the and he was what do >> he went home and committed suicide.

[00:33:04]Why >> does he have >> Why >> doesn't get revenge?

[00:33:09]>> Cuz he saw so clearly >> he's going to lose and >> HE SAW SO CLEAR that if someone would listen to him, he would win. And he SAW WITH EQUAL CLARITY THAT if they're not going to LISTEN TO HIM, IT'S FINISHED.

[00:33:23]He didn't take his life. He took his life.

[00:33:28]So you understand that a person smart can anticipate things that nobody else can see. Right.

[00:33:36]If you're smart enough, you can see far into the future. The is the smartest guy who ever lived.

[00:33:43]And together, in other words, your question is how would the why would he think that there's no world? The answer is because he's the not he's close to the world.

[00:34:04]Forgive me if you're using these because they're really so inappropriate. They're so grub because he plans ahead infinitely.

[00:34:12]>> But you can't say that we're taking the world out of the picture and then keeping the world out of the picture.

[00:34:16]>> The world was never in the picture. The image is in the picture.

[00:34:19]>> But you're saying the abisher is predicting the world being in the picture. The area is presenting everything that could possibly be ever.

[00:34:30]>> At the end of the day, the whole point of the mouth is to prot.

[00:34:40]That's exactly what the is saying. No, there was no actual malus. But the union of exists by the but that's not so now we did one thing did six lines I was really hoping to do two today but okay proved that if there's no world there's no mouth right the next issue is midas the next sh is midas that you can't have a mid without a world, right? He's going to say there there's no people you can't feel. And if the person's not here, but you know that there's a person someplace else, you could feel that too, but if there's nobody else in the universe, but you there's no possibility to feel. And not only can you not have feeling, there's no other people, you have to be close to them.

[00:35:39]I'm coming in one minute. One minute.

[00:35:41]Oh, you're you're not the announcer.

[00:35:44]This will have to be on next year.