Everyone's FURIOUS About What Sid Said (on Mamdani)... But Is He Wrong?

Added: 2026-06-02

[00:00:00]So, part of our first-ever live taping of the Aaron Mulan show in New York City has gone viral. Sid Rosenberg, it's nothing new for him. This is the moment.

[00:00:12]Watch.

[00:00:13]>> This guy can't win again. That's the bottom line. This is the worst mayor in the history of New York City. He's the most dangerous politician in the history of our country. If anybody out here tonight actually voted for Mumdani, shame on you because I am seeing way too many Jewish people at Gracie Mansion and hanging out with the mayor, telling me how good he is. He's a horrible person.

[00:00:34]He hates you. He wants you dead. He wants you dead. He's the only mayor in the history of our city that will not show up Sunday at the Israeli Day Parade. I don't want him there. He's the last person I want to see there. Who wants a terrorist at the Israeli Day Parade? But he's got to go.

[00:00:48]>> He hates you. He wants you dead. He wants you dead.

[00:00:51]>> You actually believe that Mayor Mumdani wants Jews to be dead?

[00:00:56]>> I'm not sure he doesn't. That's my answer.

[00:00:57]>> What basis do you have for that?

[00:00:59]>> I don't think he cares either way.

[00:01:01]>> I mean to say that he wants people dead is a scary thing for people to believe and you have a lot of people who follow you.

[00:01:06]>> Prove me wrong. When you had two opportunities to put buffer zones in front of synagogues and shuls, he did neither one. He celebrated Nakba Day.

[00:01:13]Listen, if I say something that's a little inflammatory, he says stuff every day that's inflammatory. Tough. Every opportunity he fails. You're doing a good job. Thank you very much.

[00:01:23]>> Now, some of the responses uh well, to borrow their terminology, unhinged.

[00:01:30]Now, think about it.

[00:01:32]The job of any mayor, any leader, whether it be of a city, of a state, of a nation, is to keep its people safe.

[00:01:41]And not just the people they particularly like.

[00:01:44]All the people.

[00:01:46]And if you're in a position of power and leadership, it is your job to do every single thing within your power to keep them safe.

[00:01:56]Answer me this. Has Mayor Mamdani done everything in his power to keep the Jewish community in New York City safe?

[00:02:05]Hell, no.

[00:02:07]And not only has he refused to take the appropriate action almost every time it's put in front of him.

[00:02:15]He's done the opposite. He's contributed to one of the most unsafe environments in New York City for Jews ever.

[00:02:23]So, is it that unhinged that Sid Rosenberg would say he wants them dead?

[00:02:29]The opposite of wanting someone dead is doing everything in your power to keep them alive if you're in a position to do so.

[00:02:36]Mamdani's done nothing of the sort.

[00:02:40]The rhetoric that he uses when it comes to the world's only Jewish state is, well, insane.

[00:02:47]We've got, of course, Bibi would be arrested and oh, it's a genocide, even though it is nothing of the sort. The ICC says that, too, by the way, Mayor.

[00:02:55]When you talk like that and when you demonize the world's only Jewish state, you demonize Jews.

[00:03:02]He's supported boycotts.

[00:03:04]He encourages violent protests against Jews in New York City, then does absolutely nothing to stop them.

[00:03:11]Did you not see the images coming out over the past month or so, let alone since October 7th? Jews harassed in the streets outside synagogues, worse, attacked.

[00:03:21]What has he done to stop it? Nothing.

[00:03:25]His new bestie, Mahmoud Khalil, well, sorry, he was the instigator, the leader, the organizer of the illegal encampments on college campuses that targeted Jews specifically. They were assaulted physically, attacked, pro-Hamas propaganda everywhere.

[00:03:42]By the way, Hamas are a designated terror group, just in case you hadn't noticed. The woman that Mayor Mamdani has given his life to in love.

[00:03:53]His soulmate celebrated the death of Jews on October 7th. Celebrated it.

[00:04:01]So, sorry if the person that you love and choose to spend your life with celebrates the death of Jews, is it that unhinged that someone in New York City right now would say he wants us dead?

[00:04:14]The reaction is absurd. Again, it's all the same repeat offenders, of course, and you know, oh, Mehdi Hasan. Gee, if he doesn't like it, well, badge of honor. That's a tick.

[00:04:26]But again, this reaction is well, it's just really silly, to be honest. Prove him wrong.

[00:04:33]Prove him wrong. What is this mayor doing right now to ensure the safety of a community in his city that he was elected to represent, including by some of them, insanely?

[00:04:46]Prove Sid wrong.

[00:04:48]Sorry, you can't. What has he done that is tangible to improve the safety of Jews in New York City?

[00:04:57]And then tell me what's the opposite of that.

[00:05:01]We'll see you next time on the Erin Molan Show.

[00:05:07]>> [music]