Debate With Arnab: First Bakrid Invite, Then Butchered, Surya Pratap Family Seek Justice

Added: 2026-06-02

[00:00:08]refreshing as Arnab Gowami on the debate.

[00:00:26]Ladies and gentlemen, the problem with our country's media is they want to always walk that fine line of fake neutrality.

[00:00:38]They don't want to take a position on a case like that of a 17-year-old boy called Surya.

[00:00:46]Surya was killed.

[00:00:48]He was killed and stabbed to death on Bakr Eid by people who wanted him to watch them halal a goat.

[00:01:01]The problem with this Hindu boy Surya is that he did not want to watch a goat being sacrificed and then being bled to death. It offended him. Maybe it offended his personal sensitivities.

[00:01:15]Maybe and we should be ready to say this, maybe it offended his religious sensitivities.

[00:01:22]Are the religious sensitivities of Hindus not something the Indian media should talk about?

[00:01:29]Are sensitivities only for those from the minority communities or Muslims?

[00:01:36]What happens when Surya refused to watch a goat being bled to death? He was stabbed to death himself by a person who called himself his friend. And my point is this ladies and gentlemen, we do not want to even take the names of the accused in this case because you see the main accused is Assad. Others named are Nawab, Farhan, Atif and one more. Total five accused.

[00:02:10]Total five accused.

[00:02:12]The media is avoiding talking about this case as strongly as it should, especially the so-called English-speaking media because they want to be secular. Is this secularism?

[00:02:23]Is remaining quiet about the killing of surya secularism?

[00:02:31]Does saying that Hindu lives matter does it make you commonal?

[00:02:37]And do Hindus are they not supposed to have any sensitivities?

[00:02:43]If Muslims are so sensitive, so vocal that if someone infringes on their rights, on their freedom, on their liberties, on their feelings, they hit back against their so-called oppressors.

[00:02:55]I'm asking tonight, what about the sentiments of the Hindu community?

[00:03:01]Why are the wolves quiet about a 17year-old boy who was killed because they refused to watch a goat being sacrificed?

[00:03:12]No one spoke about it loudly enough because you see if you speak on this the walks will say you're majoritarianism you're being majoritarian rubbish none of them spoke about it Rahul Gandhi pin drop silence did not speak about it naturally assuduin did not speak where was Asadui noi's condemnation of Surya's murder on 30th May 2026 he spoke about Namaz on roads the very day after Surya was murdered he did not speak he will speak on Namaz on roads which is wrong but he did not speak a single word about a 17-year-old Hindu boy was first taunted and then stabbed on bakari to make a point they wanted to make a point of stabbing and killing a Hindu boy problem in our country. Some people are so secular they don't want to talk about it. Where was the president of the Jamaati hind malana mandi so loud often speaking about the politics of intimidation? Where was he? Where was he?

[00:04:29]Was the taunt halal taunt to surya commalism or not? Seven armed men ambushing a Hindu boy on Bakr Eid. Was it the politics of intimidation or not?

[00:04:41]Where is the pseudocular lobby today?

[00:04:45]All quiet. Ladies and gentlemen, all of them who always speak on every other case were woefully silent.

[00:04:54]All these voices ladies and gentlemen ranging from Oi, Molana Arshad Madni, Shahi Imm say Ahmed Bkari and the usual ecosystem of secular intellectuals, activists and opposition leaders. They all spoke so much on the Nupour Sharma case but they did not speak on Surya and that is my only point tonight. Why was Surya killed? Do Hindu lives matter or not? Let's debate.

[00:05:41]He was 17 years old, a class 11 student and his name was Surya Prattab Johan.

[00:05:51]What started as a festival day interaction ended in a murder case that shocked Gazyabad. According to police and witness accounts, Surya had gone to meet people known to him in Kora Colony on Bakri when an argument broke out.

[00:06:10]Friends of the victim claimed the accused asked Surya if he had ever seen a goat sacrifice and told him, "Come, we will show you." before the situation escalated.

[00:06:24]Police say the argument turned violent and Surya was stabbed multiple times. He later succumbed to his injuries.

[00:06:34]Days later, the case took another dramatic turn. Main accused Assad who police say was absconding and carrying a reort was killed in a police encounter during an operation in Gazyabad. Police claim he opened fire while trying to escape.

[00:07:01]Encounter.

[00:07:25]The family says the fight for justice is not over because other accused are still under investigation.

[00:07:47]The big concern is no Muslim voice has spoken against this egregious attack.

[00:08:19]And the bigger question remains, how did a teenager lose his life over a dispute that should never have turned deadly?

[00:08:44]Okay, ladies and gentlemen, uh with us on the debate this evening, I have Rohan Gupta of the BJP, Shantanu Gupta. He's a well-known right-leaning author, Subuhi Khan, president and national convenor of the raashtra Jagran Aban.

[00:09:00]I have with us today Dr. Shaw Jamai, leader of the all-India Majali Sayiadul Muslim, Tariq Ahmed Lari of the Samwadi party. I can see Harish Muhammad Ibrahim uh from Chennai. He's a political analyst. Thank you very much. Uh if Harish if if it had been a Muslim who would have been killed because he objected to his religious sensitivities being targeted. Then would all all Muslim hardline voices have been quiet?

[00:09:44]No.

[00:09:47]But you see, Surya was a Hindu. He was somebody's son.

[00:09:53]>> And he was stabbed to death because some Muslims wanted him to watch them halal a goat.

[00:10:02]And this is the tragedy about some Muslim leaders and many members of the Muslim community that because Surya was a Hindu, it's all right. Hindus should be taught a lesson. Hindu boys should be brought in told that we will stab a goat. Halal a goat or this is assertion of you know sort of Muslim superiority by some people on a 17year-old boy and if you disagree you will be killed.

[00:10:32]I am quite shocked Harish at the abject and pitiable silence of so many Muslim leaders on cases like this. I'm sure you were also quiet. Can you explain your silence?

[00:10:43]>> No, of course I wouldn't be quiet for all these kind of heinous crimes which happens in any form in any religion for that matter. It has to be reprimanded.

[00:10:52]It has to be given a stringent punishment at any given cost. There is no second thought about it. But the same unanimous voices should be heard for any kind of discrimination, any kind of lynching according to any kind of religion in India for the several years after the BJP come to rule and I don't have any I don't have to mince my words in condemning this one and the accuse has to be napped and they have to brought behind bars at any given point of time immediately without even giving a second fair chance. No, no, you have to you have to talk. I will force you to talk about the larger issue out here.

[00:11:27]You see Rohan, they just want to see if anyone anywhere anything kind of comments are being made. No, it's not anyone. Surya is a Hindu boy and he was stabbed by four or five members of the Muslim community because he did not want to watch the a goat being halal.

[00:11:53]Do you understand how specific this is?

[00:11:55]Rohan, they don't want to talk about the specifics. I think it's important to talk about the specifics. Rohan, not talking about the specifics will not help here.

[00:12:06]>> The problem here is now the the selective approach of these people. I I'll make you remember incident of Mohammad Deepak where he saved some minority uh old guy and there was news everywhere even Rahul Gandhi calls him he was a hero on social media. So that time these people will come out and tell why is such a selective secularism. Is this a secularism? If something is wrong which is happening against Hindus, why can't you speak out? That is what the secularism means. It cannot be selective. It cannot be only for one community. I'm not saying that this is justified or that is justified. Any kind of such incident obviously should be condemned. But when you do it selectively that clearly shows the mindset that your mindset is not secular. You just want to politics of religion where particular thing is important to you and other thing is not important to you. And that's why people don't trust this kind of so-called secular approach. That is a visual are now where these people come out in in numbers large numbers when something happens against Muslim and they are quiet when something happens against Hindus.

[00:13:05]>> I think it was very important. I mean because it happened on Bakr Eid right there should have been a stronger sort of I think at least sub because it happens on Bakar Eid. I thought at least now these Muslim leaders will come and say something that on Bakr Eid you are forcing a Hindu to watch a halal. What are what is what what what is the point you are trying to prove right? uh Subuhi and Show Jamai and Surya Prattab Chawan his name is Surya Chawan he's a Hindu boy right on Bakar he's stabbed today voices like Shib Jamai should have been on the streets protesting about it but no somewhere they seem to be watching in a very passive way >> this is nothing related to Bakar or Halahal this is nothing the incident was different you know there is a league love affairs between the surya and the sister of that assad. So there was a confrontation between them and there was also the enemity between them before them they they were friends they were the neighbors. So this matter is nothing related to the bakar or halal don't this is a greatest disservice to the nation if you lie and make a full story to fit the agenda of the BJP. There's no I will tell you how is it today.

[00:14:26]>> One minute wait one minute. Uh one one minute one minute. First of all, first of all uh show just one show a minute.

[00:14:33]Show a minute a minute.

[00:14:35]It's very it's very dense. Uh 1 minute can you can you not can you one minute just be quiet for a MINUTE SHOW WHERE WHERE this >> then why don't you just remain quiet between the >> I want to I want to now you see it related to one minute one one minute one minute subi will give the contrary point of view since you have no credible source to say that it was not you get your facts right and then I'll get someone else on the right it's disturbing you subi and someone else >> not pardonable Thank you. Please ask me to not intervene when I did not support and someone else. Thank you. I said that once you want me to say it five times.

[00:15:17]Yeah. Thank you.

[00:15:18]>> This is this is not how I debate. Yeah.

[00:15:20]Thank you.

[00:15:29]Mr. He's saying this violence is not at all related to Bakr. Please don't compare apples with oranges. The both of them were friends earlier. It does not matter whether they were friends earlier or not. It does not matter why Suratab Choan was stabbed. What matters is the silence of Muslim leaders as you mentioned. And what matters is this that these Muslim kids are groomed from a very young age to practice this violence.

[00:16:21]normalizing violence.

[00:16:35]Wait your turn please. Wait your turn sir.

[00:16:45]How conveniently how easily conscience remorse violence.

[00:17:09]Child violation.

[00:17:14]Childare famous international cricket.

[00:17:42]and Shahid Afridi was laughing.

[00:18:00]I want to raise a few factual points.

[00:18:03]First point, the question is was he killed for being a Hindu? Let us go to the mood point. Shantanu Gupta. Was he killed for being a Hindu? First point I because because I have other panelists to party. Can you not do these windows because show has a bad habit of behaving really badly and I don't want to be disturbed tonight. Yeah, show you behave yourself. You can talk. You don't want to behave yourself then I can't have you on my debate.

[00:18:30]>> If you're not open to contrary opinion I don't encourage this. I've had a previous incident with you and you're please don't put him on air. It's not enjoyable for me.

[00:18:38]>> I came to >> I mean Shhat what are you doing? You know she show I'm not here to encourage you.

[00:18:44]>> I'm here to make some points in a rational way. First point is was Surya killed for being a Hindu.

[00:18:50]Were the date and the day a coincidence?

[00:18:55]First point, the murder did not happen on a random Tuesday.

[00:19:00]It happened on May 28th, 2026, the day of Bakr Eid, right? Which is the festival of sacrifice. The accused chose this day to invite Surya. The accused chose this day to invite Surya.

[00:19:16]Yeah.

[00:19:17]>> The accused chose this day to gather a group. The accused chose this day to arm themselves to execute the attack.

[00:19:28]This is my first point. Shantu, I have many points on this. We need to debate it. We need to be open-minded. Shantu and just to educate your viewers about the incident. It happened in Koda in Gazabad which is not very far away from where I'm sitting where you are sitting right. It's just across sector 62 from Nida is also adjoining Delhi. Right?

[00:19:48]That's the place I'm saying. I'm telling you this is a very urban place. This happen in daylight.

[00:20:22]And then they took HIM AND STARTED STABBING HIM.

[00:20:28]His father said exactly that was dialog you're showing the scene exactly that makes a video.

[00:20:47]Can you imagine that? Can you imagine that? and and and likes likes of your friend Marfa Kanum to Rana to Zoe to to to Sabah Nakwi to to Madana Molana to Sudin Noasi all are shut pra silent they're finding some love story here and there just condemn it this is happening in daylight next to NCR AND just shut up your statement.

[00:21:22]>> Shantanu. Louder. Please. Louder. Don't Don't let him disturb now. Shantanu.

[00:21:28]Louder for Shantanu. Please. What are you doing on the audio floor? Please do not interfere. You must have the courage to listen to the truth. Uh Tariq. Let him complete. Do not intervene. He's making a very strong point. You have no right to disturb his narrative. He has every right to respond. When the truth becomes very uncomfortable for you, then you people like you, you don't want anyone to speak. Facts are being put here. Shantanu has every right to speak.

[00:21:54]I will not censor him. Shantanu just give me half a minute. I'm saying the earlier government's run used to used to run on a philosophy.

[00:22:09]Today we we have a government which says mafia committee in two days these mafias are gone and let me read the names loud and clear. Assad, Nawab, Farhan, Atif.

[00:22:30]Now I this is happening in that when there is Yogi.

[00:22:37]Can you imagine what will happen in UP?

[00:22:39]Can you imagine now what used to happen in UP before 2017? Yeah.

[00:22:52]No, the the people the the the second point is the second point is the point the uh Shantanu the only larger point I'm trying to make here is that some people are unwilling to accept the truth or they want to uh put a blindfold on themselves.

[00:23:13]Now what is the what is the family of the victim said and why should we disbelieve the family of the victim?

[00:23:19]>> The family of the victim is saying then when accused Assad called surya he said come here let us celebrate Eid.

[00:23:30]>> He said he said uh come here let us celebrate Eid.

[00:23:35]Then Tarik and Harish and Syad Surya did not want to go. He was forced to come under a false pretext. He was lured there. He said that you come celebrate Eid with us. Then when he was there a total of seven people went there. They all were armed with knives and they attacked him on Bakar Eid. And now we are being told do not mention the fact that he was killed on Bakarid. Do not mention the fact that he was Hindu. Do not mention the fact that there were seven people all armed with knives. They were all waiting. This is not a motorcycle fight that got out of hand.

[00:24:16]Seven men had prearmed themselves with knives for a boy who did not even want to come. This was a hunt.

[00:24:24]>> I want to make it clear Rohan, >> this was a hunt and Surya was hunted.

[00:24:30]Surya was hunted. Yes, Tariq. Now you can speak. Now you can speak and Rohan will respond after that. Sorry. Now.

[00:24:37]>> Yes.

[00:24:39]>> Yeah. After that, please don't interfere. First of all, it's looking like a road rage.

[00:25:01]stabbing.

[00:25:03]Oh, he wanted like that now.

[00:25:08]You wanted No. How did you say that? No. No. What do you mean?

[00:25:17]What did you want?

[00:25:21]Oh my god. Yeah. This is a road rage stabbing a person. Oh my god. Road rage is stabbing a road with a friend.

[00:25:30]is a friend. They know each other from quite some time right now.

[00:25:36]Please keep your trap shut. Let me finish first.

[00:25:43]You wanted a kurwani now.

[00:26:15]We know your piles have been disturbed.

[00:26:17]We know we are seeing the blood from your mouth.

[00:26:25]We know your piles are busted from your mouth.

[00:26:32]How you are born in water is clearly visible. How you are brought up.

[00:26:52]You all will go where you deserve.

[00:27:06]Shantu road is that MOTORCYCLE one one point here one point here one minute I don't want Today I want to ask a point. I'll get Rohan on the other side. When a Hindu boy when a Hindu boy is killed by seven most of them I think Muslim it is told Rohan that it is a case of road rage. Can you be can you be quiet please for a minute? I please don't you can I heard you. Why do you want to repeat it 20 times? Does it make the point stronger? Does it make your point stronger if you repeat it 20 times?

[00:27:55]If this is a case of Thank you. Thank you.

[00:28:16]Rohan Rohan Rohan Rohan. Now what is the police saying? What is the police saying? The police is saying volume down. I'm being disturbed. The police is saying that Assad's father Nawab instigated him to kill Johan. Surya Chan and Assad was given a knife and his father told him to end the story.

[00:28:43]Assad then stabbed Surya in the stomach till he collapsed on the ground covered in blood and then he fled from the spot. This did happen on Bakar and things will not be censored anymore.

[00:28:59]Rohan they are trying to cover this up saying normal crime.

[00:29:02]>> Absolutely not. The problem is they are not ready to believe police statement also and they just want to say that it's a road race.

[00:29:11]Why are you silent?

[00:29:15]Why you are then shying away from condemning such a horrific incident?

[00:29:20]Road police statement. Are you countering the police statement? No, you cannot. This is not road rage. This is murder. This is a cold-blooded murder.

[00:29:28]And you have all of us together we must have to condemn it strongly. So that this kind of antisocial elements don't have courage even to do this because you are converting into Hindu Musulman by not opposing it but these kind of people the antisocial animals whatever religion is they are getting benefit out of it because then they are shying away behind the religion this is not about Hindu Muslma this is again the humanitarian issues and still you are silent so I think this is really unfortunate that now today in debate everybody unocally should have opposed this kind of incident and told that These kind of people should be treated LIKE THIS ONLY.

[00:30:03]BUT NO, THEY ARE SAYING SOMEBODY saying that is road rage. SOMEBODY SAYING giving example.

[00:30:25]Why? Why this kind of attitude? This is creating the issues between Hindu and Musulwman. This kind of attitude is responsible for the difference between Hindus and >> Why have the Malvies not condemned it?

[00:30:36]Why have the Muslim leaders remained quiet on it? What they are trying to say is that we will pacify uh the hardliners. We are with the hardliners. We are with the Hindu haters and shami please don't shout in an indecent way. Okay. I will go to SAS right now. It is an opportunity for people like you say the Sabbas to not make this about protecting the killers because they are Muslim.

[00:31:03]>> Nobody is protecting the >> or of or of trying to underplay this as an incident with no religious overtones.

[00:31:11]>> Firstly, Arnab.

[00:31:12]>> Yeah. No, one way you heard me on both.

[00:31:14]You heard me on both. Yeah.

[00:31:16]>> I did. Of course I did. And I will definitely answer you. Firstly, I believe I have comments. Come back to the pointing this. Yeah, this is not time for your shing serious incident on this topic. It's very unfortunate that a mother has lost.

[00:31:40]>> Don't give me the general secular rubbish. No. Can you come to the point?

[00:31:43]There are seven Muslim people who have come and killed a boy after inviting him to celebrate Eid with them. Yeah. Now, let's deal with it.

[00:31:51]Firstly, let me question Rohan Gupta, Subhi Khani and Mr. Shantanu to show me one proof that he's been killed because he is a Hindu. They will absolutely have no proof.

[00:32:03]I'm saying my friend FIRST OF ALL WHAT HAS happened how can you talk like this in the beginning and then every next STATEMENT IS SOMETHING DIFFERENT HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT KILLED BECAUSE OF HINDU THEN WHY IS HE WHY IS HE TELL THAT HE'S BEEN HINDU WHY IS HE WHO HE NEVER WANTED to see how the police to on what you know WHY YOU ANSWER THAT ON THE DEBATE ONLY BECAUSE HE'S THIS IS UNFORTUNATE MY FRIEND this is the real face ON WHAT >> I THOUGHT AT LEAST YOU ARE SENSIBLE BUT today the way you have asked the question that he's not killed because the Hindu I think this is unfortunate who you answer SIMPLE QUESTION WHY IS HE KILLED >> WHO GIVES YOU THE RIGHT TO DO THE ENCOUNTER >> WHY is he killed do YOU HAVE THE ANSWER >> YOU HAVE NO YOU HAVE NO >> OKAY I'LL ASK YOU THIS question let me put it this way faith in the let me let me put it this way now Assad say the saddabas okay listen to me and I bring subi here let's do a role reversal on this harish and subi if roles are reversed harish and it is a Muslim boy who was killed on holi with a cow related taunt then national media opposition secular voices, pseudocular voices would amplify this at a commal atrocity. They would make this a case study of majoritarianism. They would not look at the fine details, try to find ways on how this should not be seen to be communal. They would have asked for chief ministerial level, prime ministerial level intervention. They would have written to the Washington Post to publish an oped from their favorite columnists to make this an issue about how minorities have been targeted. This is a fact. Am I wrong, Subi? These are the kind of cases that this that the that the fake pseudo brigade looks for. Am I wrong here?

[00:34:10]Harish. Right. But am I wrong here?

[00:34:15]H >> No, no, no. You're you're pretty much >> Yeah. Thank you. Thank you for acknowledging I'm right now. Please.

[00:34:20]>> Let him continue. I I'll come back to you. So, wait. So, wait. My point was role reversal. If it was a Muslim boy who had been killed on Holi with a cow related taunt, then Harish Mouhammad Ibrahim would be tweeting nonstop on it.

[00:34:35]>> Right. All of them. All of them.

[00:34:38]>> Had the victim been a Muslim by now country would have been labeled as Lynchan. Correct. country isolated.

[00:35:03]This is the kind of hypocrisy, selective outrage.

[00:35:18]I want to repeat it. I want to reiterate it. My main focus is on the fact that why these kids, the youth of my community is become so violent. Why violence has become so normal for them?

[00:35:40]Because unlike these Muslim leaders, unlike them, I am concerned about the mental health of the children of my community.

[00:35:59]I am not sure about the authenticity, but video actually and he's wearing it as a badge of honor.

[00:36:30]It is evident from that video.

[00:36:35]Harish Harish see.

[00:36:36]>> Okay. May I raise har on the reversal test. I said that if the roles were reversed, if it was a Muslim boy who was killed on Holi with a cow related taunt then how much of a global issue would you people have made it by now? Please answer that question. Don't avoid it.

[00:36:54]>> No. No. I don't want ahead. Don't avoid it.

[00:36:57]>> No. I don't I don't avoid and I don't mince my words as you know and I want to put it clear you don't want to go ahead for road reversal and all because I I come from a background which always stood fast for all kind of such kind of heinous crimes we should reprimand them it is highly condemnable at the highest order there is no second thought about it and as I say always that if you want to show any kind of your supremacy by killing someone by killing >> all this is general talk you know again Rohan same old if I am this if anybody is hurt if there is any issue if anything happens if anybody does but they don't want to talk specifically about this case Rohan >> that is what unfortunately be specific on the case you want me to do >> we have been debating for last 42 minutes none of them have at least once condemned what has happened even on humanitarian that is that is the irony of the situation that is the irony of their reality that The irony of so-called secular parties or the people that they are secular only when particular things happen. They are not secular when something happens against Hindus and they have to accept it. You say whatever you want to say but condemning this such a such a horrific incident. Why are you linking it to the religion?

[00:38:14]>> This is surprising. This is really really shocking. I never expected any of you at least to counter this what you are seeing on the screen. A mother has lost his son. Can you see the mother statement? What he has lost? what she has lost and you are not with your shows. What kind of message you want for your narrative? Do you want to set example for other people to do the same thing to others and you don't condemn?

[00:38:36]You are setting the example for other to do the same thing. AT LEAST COME OUT AND TELL OPENLY THAT WHAT HAS happened is wrong and you condemn it.

[00:38:42]>> What stops you from that silent >> why can't you WHY CAN'T YOU CONDEMN THIS? You tell >> don't shout. Please give me a second.

[00:38:48]>> NO, I'M NOT SHOUTING. I'M ASKING YOU SIMPLE QUESTION. WHY CAN'T YOU CONDEMN IT?

[00:38:52]>> What I was doing were you listening or what?

[00:38:54]>> Why can't you condemn this?

[00:38:56]>> What I was doing? You are not listening there. I WAS NOT THE HIGHEST. YOU ARE NOT. NO.

[00:39:01]>> COME ON.

[00:39:01]>> YOU HAVE BEEN JUSTIFYING IT.

[00:39:03]>> GO. YOU HAVE BEEN JUSTIFYING it from the beginning.

[00:39:06]>> You are saying that IT'S A ROAD. YOU ARE SAYING THAT THIS IS THIS. NO.

[00:39:10]>> NOTHING. NO. NO.

[00:39:12]>> This is something horrific and you HAVE TO CONDEMN IT. DON'T make it Hindu Muslim. That's the problem with you people because you set a wrong example in the minds OF PEOPLE AND YOU SET WRONG EXAMPLE IN MIND of antisocials who do this kind of activities by not unconddemning it >> this is not done this is not done my friend on national TV something better is expected out of you as a Indian also we don't believe in such hatred we don't like this kind of scenes because this sends a wrong precedent to all others also around across the country so at least on the debate we should have been univocal and just equivocal and just say that no this is absolutely horrific.

[00:39:48]>> I'm not even I'm not even say the bas I'm not even talking about provocation.

[00:39:53]I'm not talking about the case in Ratlam in Madhya Pradesh where a severe cow head is found right where meat is put outside a Hindu home shortly after cleaning. Uh I'm not talking about a case in Merritt where a Muslim man is caught cooking meat inside the Daar temple premises on Bakarid and then arrested after protest by Hindu activists. I'm not talking about those cases. I'm simply asking you to acknowledge that a Hindu boy was killed Bakar in a very calculated way.

[00:40:26]>> I heard don't don't give general comments. Don't give today general comments. General comments don't make any sense. Anab I will answer Rohan Gupta. I think I I do my head to Rohan Gupta first BJP spokesperson to say please don't make it Hindu Muslim. The same request Arnab kindly do not make it Hindu Muslim. Please condemn it for the hear me out. Hear me out condemn it my friend. Uh okay with a hand on my heart my dear Rohan Gupta I condemn this underally but I also WANT YOU TO KEEP A HAND ON YOUR HEART AND CONDEMN the killing OF I WANT YOU TO CONDEMN THE KILLING OF I WANT YOU TO CONDEMN the killing of >> today you said don't do it Hindu Muslim I will not DO IT HINDU MUSLIM KEEP YOUR HANDS ON YOUR hearts I want you don't do All those companies >> don't tell that this is not the road or this IS THE REASON WHATEVER IS THE REASON THIS IS INSIDE INDIA YOU HAVE giving the reason are you even aware sir that's why I ask you question you know that I never speak all those surprising that when you started condemning I just said that WHAT HAS HAPPENED IS COMPLETELY rather than GOING today it is absolutely shameful This IS THE DUPLICATE OF THE BHAGA PARTY. I I SHAME ON THE PEOPLE WHO DO Hindu Muslim.

[00:41:58]No, but but is this a time I think it would I think it would help a great deal.

[00:42:02]>> Stop Hindu Muslim.

[00:42:03]>> Uh I I'll tell you one thing. It would help a great deal.

[00:42:06]>> All I'm asking for Shantanu today is introspection from the Muslim community.

[00:42:13]>> Deep no deep introspection after the Sudia incident. Why Muslim community?

[00:42:18]WHY MUSLIM PROBLEM with this is the problem you're introspection among the Muslim community. Allow me to complete my sentence. Please don't interrupt me.

[00:42:27]>> Let me answer. Can No, no, no. You please be remain quiet and stop. No, you have no right to stop me midsentence.

[00:42:34]So, so don't don't stop me mid-sentence.

[00:42:36]Say, listen to me.

[00:42:38]>> It is time for deep introspection among the Muslim community >> as to why. Come on here. Let me complete what I'm saying as to why their so-called leaders are quiet on the Sudia incident. Question the leadersh don't of course I'm questioning the leaders that is if you let me complete MY SENTENCE COMMUNITY WHAT DOES COMMUNITY HAVE TO do let me answer sub >> the leaders question the leaders start with that community is violence >> what do you want to question subi about okay let's get subui on because he wants to debate with her yeah >> that is wrong all my life I have c celebrated bakr and not once have I done any halal on bakr what kind of fake news is she peddling SUBI KHAN WHAT KIND OF FAKE news peddling are YOU DOING ON THE THIS IS MUSLIM HOUSEHOLD.

[00:43:41]fake news.

[00:43:45]That is a perspective. It is not fake news. That is a perspective. Let her complete what she's saying. YOU SAY WHAT YOU WANT.

[00:43:52]Children now. Now I go back to the issue. Thank you very much. I'VE DEALT WITH THAT. MY point is violence in front of them.

[00:44:01]>> You are also going on another track.

[00:44:02]Subi. I want to talk about Surya. You're making it another issue which I don't want to focus on. I am talking about why the Muslim community Shantanu cannot put pressure tarik I'm coming to you why the Muslim community cannot put pressure on all their leaders to issue a joint statement right uh condemning and asking for severe action against the killers of Surya if they had then it would make people feel that they have a heart that they have sensitivity maybe they would have even got some sympathy right I don't know why that has become so difficult almost an ego issue Shantanu unmute Shantanu unmute and so-called three responsible people on your debate one said it's a road race one said it's a love case one said prove me that he's killed because he's a Hindu on channel on live debate when laks and people are listening 9:00 Friday they're not even ready to agree. They're not ready to agree.

[00:45:09]>> You said Shantanu according to Khan ONLY YOU SAID not anyone youth is like this REPORT and you Please. Thank you.

[00:45:40]Let him complete. I will let you make your point after him. Thank you.

[00:45:43]>> And the irony and the irony and the sad part is that what kind of leaders are they getting? They they get the leaders like Adam Khan. They get the leadership, right? And I think that's that's that's the problem with Muslim community that they have very few voices like Subi Khan who is thinking why they are not part of the Indian economy.

[00:46:05]when India is growing why why even from London to New York% I think why they disproportionately on crime do I direct for you it's a very important point but I can't directly You have to cut yourself. You continue being a booker of yoga. We don't need lessons.

[00:46:40]Muslim community does not need lessons from a book of yoga. That's what you are.

[00:46:47]You need your credibility. Community is breeding people like you need a big inside.

[00:47:04]WHAT are what are your beliefs in the name of QURAN that people like you HINDU MUSLIMS WE WILL ALWAYS BE brothers people like you divide us take the first opportunity divide us people like you divide us we will not be divided. Hindus are our brothers. We will start people like you. Our community is thriving in our beautiful Hindustan.

[00:47:44]People like you. See the visuals on the screen. See the visual on the screen.

[00:47:47]Seven Muslim killing.

[00:47:49]See the visuals on the screen.

[00:47:54]See the visual on the screen.

[00:47:59]He was 11th GRADE STUDENT. STOP HINDU MUSLIM. I'm telling you the day you stop doing HinduM.

[00:48:37]pepti will go on will call you by you will find them will not work. I know you are a group of men.

[00:49:00]You are doing this for your benefit but this will not help you. At the end you have to meet the right and be a good person in your life for wore now to your sensible side.

[00:49:13]>> I appeal to your sensible side.

[00:49:16]>> Right. The the fact is this incident is provoked with religious taunt. The butchery is on a religious day and the day of sacrifice.

[00:49:29]Seven people call him to celebrate their Muslim festival. He goes, he's put in a trap. Then seven armed people surround him and the father gives his son and tells him to kill him.

[00:49:45]In all of this, unfortunately, on the side of the accused, there is a perverted interpretation of religious symbolism that we are going to sacrifice him on that day. Let's be a little reasonable now, right Rohan? We must not be unreasonable. Rohan, we must if we are to improve this country, then we must call out these things.

[00:50:08]>> So, that is what I've been saying now.

[00:50:10]>> Yeah. Rohan, can you can you make the point to harish and harish will respond to you? Yeah. See this is what I'm trying to explain you know from the beginning you are just saying that this is what has happened this is the police statement even after that and none of them they have at least condemned it openheartedly and just they are just giving the explanation no no asanita I think shankuji rightly told three people have given the different reason but none of them even condemned this shows the real side of it this role shows the real face of you this is not about any any particular guy or against Muslims something somebody has done something wrong you have to immediately come out and condemn it openly. Why it is so DIFFICULT FOR YOU? YOU can make your argument. You can give historical examples all that after you condemn it openly and tell that these kind of guys should be taken to the task. That's it.

[00:50:56]You are just debating for last 54 minutes just just for FOR FOR WHAT WHAT KIND OF message you are sending to the whole country.

[00:51:02]>> I let harish >> one of my talking good things and next question he asked that why he is killed.

[00:51:07]So you want to decide the killing is justified or not based on the reason of killing. NO, YOU CANNOT DO THAT. And then you are blaming others for Hindu Muslim. No, >> I'll let Harish respond to you briefly.

[00:51:19]Rohan, I'm running short of time. I'll let Harish respond to you briefly, please.

[00:51:22]>> Even even my opening statement and the second round I have condemned to the highest order. Any kind of such heinous crimes in the name of religious supremacy should be condemned at the highest order and the people who are behind this should be reprimanded should be brought into justice and they have to be punished at any given point of time and it has to be uh eradicated. I'm >> you still making general remarks. I wish next time we debate that you don't make any anyone kind of comments. I made very specific points but I can understand why you're skirting that. I thank you all very much. Ladies and gentlemen, remember no other channel wanted to make a big issue of the killing of Surya Prattab Jan. Only Republic did because I don't hide, neither does anyone on this channel behind a fake interpretation of neutrality. Sometimes neutrality, as I've always said, becomes a mask, a camouflage. I'll see you tomorrow. Good night and goodbye.

[00:52:39]as refreshing as a mazd.

[00:52:44]B S M E