This critique cuts through populist noise by focusing on the systemic failures behind the immigration crisis. It correctly identifies that blaming outsiders is merely a distraction from the urgent need for structural reform.
Deep Dive
Prerequisite Knowledge
- No data available.
Where to go next
- No data available.
Deep Dive
Phakelumthakathi respond Ndlozi in Illegal foreignersAdded:
Why don't South Africa and manu.
Amen.
Spenc have been in power for more than 10 years.
over political reject.
Why?
Why?
clearly on your Kuma from the the privilege perspective and and and and and privilege situation.
Please shutter.
as well That's why men can't even stand up and fight for your for your own provinces and we we promised we will help everyone.
I'm understand.
feel dead. Dead dead. They can't even think.
People can't even listen to to make sense of out of or out of industry. They can't listen. People were killed. They were brainwashed.
People can't even hear because politic has brainwashed people. The first thing people want to do is to defend a leader.
That's the first thing. It doesn't matter whether he makes sense or he doesn't make sense. Whether the person is poor or not poor or they are working or not working, the first thing they want to do is to defend a leader.
Gina, we will win this one.
We will win this one. You must know your leaders can try your best. We know they have businesses with the taxpayers money that they were getting from parliament. They went and established businesses and that's why they are forced by those governments to defend um am illegal immigrants and and thugs and and criminals that are killing our people and kids.
I want to be short as much as I can. I want to respond to Dr. Anloi. When Dr. Anloi said the foreigners, we are the ones those who are putting them in our garages. Dr. Andrew, I'm disappointed my brother. You know, I respect you that much. I respect you a lot, a lot. I respect you a lot. You know Dr. Lus that South Africans the high unemployment rate in Gagana. You know that people are hungry, people are starving because the government, the leadership is failing them. You create job opportunities for people. Create job opportunities for people.
They end up doing those things because of that they are unemployed.
And Dr. losing my brother, you are talking from a a a good heart that h a Africans must unite, you know, and I can hear your statement. You are saying much and much they are mobilizing hate. No, no.
Foreigners already have mobilized hate against South Africans. Can't you see that? Don't turn a blind eye on that one. Foreigners, they don't like South Africans. They hate South Africans. You can even hear them when they talk on social media. You can even hear foreigners when they talk. Zimbabweans are calling us stupid.
Nigerians, they are telling us they going to stay here forcefully. So, there is nothing we can do. They are selling drugs to our kids. They are using our young girls for sexual transactions.
And you tell us that much and much they are mobilizing hate.
What hate? What hate when they trying to fix the country? You can't say that. We are in trouble, my brother. Don't turn a blind eye on that one. Do not do that.
You see what is happening here incali said now. He said to the foreigners they they do not wait for that date that was issued by Pagalamat the at the end of the end of June. They must leave peacefully peacefully so before that date arrives. That's what we want guys. Be careful is resurrecting.
ANC is coming back. They are fixing their party. Currently what ANC has done. I I I salute them. When when we are saying there is a corruption they initiated Madanga Madanga Commission and we can see that there are arrests there.
People are being arrested. Bazali Sufi now he's listening to the masses on the ground what people want and he support that he said do not wait foreigners don't wait for that date before that date arrives live peacefully you see what they are doing okay cool foreigners they were making jokes about us that no e we are failing to to get into the spa shops and all that what our government did Now they said come and get the funds. Those who want to run the tax shops to open tax shops come and apply for the funds.
That's what we want. That's what we want. Solving the problem when it that is the evidence that people shall govern. That's what is doing. They are now following freedom charter.
You know you know Dr. Let me tell you my brother, South Africans, they are the custodians of this South Africa, not not foreigners. We are the custodians of South Africa, like it or not. And we are going to do what is going what is best for our country and for our upcoming generation.
We are going to do what is best for that. We have leaders there. Some of us we can't be active because we are committed at the work on daily on daily work because that is why we are having leadership that we we nominate to represent us because most of the people they are committed on daily daily things that they are doing then you will hear someone says what are you doing when what are you doing no Dr. You can't do that. You can't program. Don't follow that brother of yours. E you left that one. Now I understand why he's behaving like this. calling parents they have heads of butter saying that saying to our president calling him rango that young boy who's having a verbal diarrhea who does not respect elders but I understand why he's doing that that guy you see as a child growing up without a father figure it's a problem this these are the results of that boy growing up without a father figure someone who will show you the the the the the the direction as a young boy how you supposed to conduct yourself as a young boy having a father sometimes is important I can see I can see that now so please don't be like that other guy that guy is yes that guy I don't want even to talk about that guy >> so that we have many >> yeah just cut it to to allow other people to talk. Thanks my brother for for this platform.
>> I really appreciate. So guys, like brother Thomas, you're next guys. Let's have 3 minutes guys. Like 3 minutes. 3 minutes guys.
Hello.
>> We can hear you my friend. How are you?
>> Um good. Um it's quite a good conversation we are having and I'm I'm happy that we are sharing both sides of the story. Uh mine it's a little bit piece of slice of the cake. Um look as Africans we are suffering from a lot of leadership failures that most of the time it remained untouched. Um, as much as South Africans might say immigrants are the causes of the problem that South Africa is facing now, I don't personally think immigrants, they are the huge causes of this. What we try, we need to uh face and what we need to sit down and talk about especially the modern day African generation. We need to talk about corruption and how we can put people in leadership accountable for whatever that we are suffering as nations. If you look into this 2008 um there was an issue in Zimbabwe. The Zimbabweans they did uprise and they wanted Zanopfab to be thrown out. Uh but what happened after that? South Africa interfered. They did a little bit of research then they said everything is fair and it's okay in Zimbabwe. So meaning that they endorsed the government of Zimbabwe that as Zimbabweans were against. I mean this is not an issue that regular South Africans would will understand but majority of the problems that Africa is facing as a nation they are not an independent issue it's a block relationship issue that is the these democratic parties that are in control they are endorsing each other to such a point that most Zimbabweans most Malawians they found it much better to run away from their own countries to come for refuge in South Africa why because South Africa which is a superpower economy it's actually endorsing the people that are causing uh lack of that are causing lack of resources in those in our own own countries. What is it that we can do together without hurting each other, without going against each other? Cuz what I'm what I'm seeing in modern day happening is something that comes always warned us that the struggle of us economically remaining fragmented, we always fight among ourselves. That is the poor. We are fighting for the crumbs of the bread. Yet there's someone who's running away with the whole bakery. It's not a Zimbabwean issue. It's not a Nigerian issue. It's us coming together like what happened back. This is the time we can repeat history where we can form unity and allies among each other and fight our governments not as fragmented as we are doing right now that we are now marching in the streets attacking each other. There are videos that are circulating. Yes, some of them might be fake stories, but now how are we going to clarify this is the real thing and this is the fake thing. But when the matches are occurring, there are people being beaten there. Yes, it's your right to say you guys you have overstayed, you're welcome, but at the same time you need to understand that this is not something that Zimbabweans alone can do cuz if now right now Zimbabweans can go and uprise against an Oop, South Africa will beg them. Why? Because these are the same guys. These guys they share a little bit of history. So we can go and fight. Zimbabweans can go and fight but the government is going to look for refugee in South Africa and the government is going indoors as much as Zimbabweans can uprise there. There's nothing that we are going to do on our own and we need South African back up.
The reason why we need South African back up because here there's a little bit of rule of law that is still into play. As much as the government is corrupt here, there's still a little bit of rule of law. So, it's a different case, but I I I I think it's hard to to put it to people that we all want to be home. No one wants to live here. No one wants to live in fear of not knowing what's going to happen next. Is my child safe? No one wants that. But this is where we are. So, we can turn our backs on each other, but we are not going to solve anything. We are just going to solve today's issue, but tomorrow we have another issue as well. So everyone everyone here needs help from each other like what we did back in the day. You know there is many opportunities for for Africans as I I am much more than modern economy. Look, we have potential to turn Africa around to be the next great power, to be the next Europe. But this comes if we can work hand in hand, work together. And now South Africans are complaining that there's a lot of immigrants here that are here in South Africa. But you understand that at home affairs right now you can get a paper a document with money you can get that document. So is that now a m citizen problem or that is a corruption issue that is happening right now? as much we always uprise when it's happening um to to the to the black people but how many Europeans are coming here without papers then are surviving on visa but no one is saying anything these guys look at the Chinese they are looting all the resources everywhere you go they there are looting but we are not fighting those what we want to fight for for the breadcrumbs so you can go as much as you say we don't want these guys here and everyone we can leave but remember there's no country that is an island as much as you don't Zimbabweans in South Africa. You need them for the growth of your economy. Right now, South Africa is economy. Most of the produce here, they're going to export. They're supporting the SAG block. So imagine if you chase a Malawian guy, you don't want them here as Min then what's going to happen if we all lock our borders? Do you think South Africa can sustain on its own? No, that does not work like that. So I mean this is a bigger issue that immigration alone is not going to solve. But that's my two cents.
you come in.
>> All right. Uh uh firstly I would love to thank uh all the all the people that have submitted uh such a wonderful submission but I think in this whole conversation we are missing the key words the key point the main reason for everything that is happening now. So the thing is South Africa is not blaming anyone for whatever that is happening now.
South Africa is not blaming is not blaming Zimbabwe. South Africa is not blaming Mozambique. South Africa is not blaming Nigerians. South Africa is blaming uh their system. The war that we are facing right now is the South Africans and the system. When they say we must go, they are not chasing us.
They are saying our brothers as you can see that we are we want to fix our own country. go there and fix your own country. To me, instead of us seeing this as an attack, I think it has to be a wakeup call. I'll speak more about Zimbabwe uh more than other countries cuz I'm a Zimbabwe. Look, we have been we we grew up misled with different information about certain tribes. You know, we have been misled countless times. We have been given false information countless times. We have been used countless times.
With the situation that is in front of us now, I think it's high time a a a young man, a young woman, a youth, a Zimbabwean must sit down and be like, but all those things that have been saying, what did they assist us with?
What did they help us with? Instead of here being busy saying South Africans what they doing, they're wrong. Are we are we even putting oursel on the mirror and ask you Zimbabwe I'm seeing on the mirror there, are you right? Why do we have to be defensive?
Are you sure sure sure that we are correct the way we are? Are you sure we are fighting the right opponent? Cuz in my view, I don't think a South African is my opponent. My opponent is my system.
My opponent is my system. So as as as Zimbabwans, as the youth of Zimbabwe, I'm morally directing this message to the youth of Zimbabwe cuz I know the old generation will tell me that you are going to be beaten. I'm tired of hearing that. But I'm I'm speaking this This message let it go straight to the youth. Are you sure we are going to be part of that generation that is going to be that our younger brothers and kids will say no they also failed they did nothing. They saw the truth but they couldn't do anything with it. They heard the truth but they couldn't act up. Are we going are we going to be that generation? Are we going to be that group that is going to be categorized as cowards?
For me I don't want to be part of that.
I don't want to be part of that group that is going to be counted as coward. I don't want to be part of that group that is going that my kids and my younger brothers will say no. They knew the truth but they didn't do anything about it. For how long have you guys been saying they're going to beat us? They're going to do this. They're going to do for how long? In other words, are you praising a beast that you're looking at and say what you're doing is right because you're beating people. Is it what you're telling us? Why do we have to praise a beast? For me, I think we need to learn from these South Africans.
South Africans got a lot of tribes, but when it comes to problems, they fight together. South South Africa got different parties, but when it comes to problems, they won't mind to have their parties suspended a bit and fight over one vision. Why can't we just do the same?
Why are we not seeing a coming together now? Why are we not seeing the Tongas?
Why are we not seeing the other 11 tribes that we have in Zimbabwe coming up and say, "You know what guys, the system divided us? Politics separated us. Politics misled us. Now it's high time we come together. Why are we not seeing such a community? Instead, we are seeing a community that comes here and say South Africa you wrong. South Africa you this." it you know it will be so exciting to know if we can have maybe a group of you that say okay match and match we see what we are doing we want the same movement but we don't have the resources we want the same movement we want to do the same thing we want the B bridge border post closed cuz if we go inside the city and we march nothing is going to happen because we are not disturbing anything but if you go there by the border and close the border millions won't get in any any country.
What will happen if million are not getting inside any country? The citizens will start to wake up that it is politics that led us to where we are now. We are divided. There is hatred because of politics, not mere civilians.
So the South Africa are not fighting with normal civilians. No, they are fighting with their system. They want their system to prioritize them. We need to be doing the same instead of coming here and say we are fighting for our rights in South Africa. Are you a South African? If I ask you to provide me your ID, is it saying South Africa or saying Zimbabwe Malawi? Go fight for your rights wherever you come from.
Let's go and fight. Let's go have our own organizations. Let's form our organization. Let's go. If you are to say like right now the movement is saying we are going to close the border.
Let's go and close the damn border.
Let's go in our numbers instead of us be coming here talking politics. I'm only hearing people talking politics. Do you know? No one is talking or seeing this in in a positive way. It's just politics over politics.
Hey, they are this. Yeah. Yeah, they are this. Can we stop politicizing everything and put ourselves in their shoes? These people have been experiencing the worst. I've been telling you guys yesterday, we have some 40-year-old people from different countries, Uganda, wherever, Nigeria, impregnating metric girls. Would you love that? Would you love to see your your younger sister, 16 year old being impregnated by a man who is 40 years and on top of that he runs away, he runs and say he he's not involved in that. How would you feel?
We are being so judgmental. Instead of us putting ourselves in their shoes, we are judging them. Instead of them trying to us trying to understand where they are coming from. No, we are not we don't even want to go where they coming from.
We are just judging everything.
Everything we judge, politicize, judge, politicize.
We cannot say Africa just because South Africans say they want to fight with their system. That's being unfair. How about we fix the system and say Africa unite? Let's go also and fix our own.
Just look right now. Look at the platform. How many Zimbabweans are you seeing with the same profile? Why can't we just have this thing? Why can't we just have this thing?
Why? Instead of coming here and fight for some rice that doesn't even belongs to you.
Your rights are in Zimbabwe, not in South Africa. Let's go, J. Let's go.
I'll hold you for now, guys. fully speaking we need to go guys like until when is my brother just like fighting for our rights here like you know it's said like if you look back in Zimbabwe like we are facing economic struggles and we run away we come to South Africa we don't have like I said we don't have medication in our hospital we don't have good roads photos are everywhere and we're busy here fighting South Africans fighting South Africans here guys and what we need to do guys South Africans hear me you don't know owe us anything like you came we came here seeking green passer and you have welcomed us I think now we have overstate our welcome so what we need to do fellow brothers from Zimbabwe we need to educate one another and go and fix our country if we don't fix our country we cannot expect South Africans to go and fix our country you know like yesterday I was moved there was this South African guy sent me a message said you know like when I get paid I'm going to send you something I want to support this movement imagine South Africans are leading the way but Zimbabweans We're busy saying like no we are here we are fine guys as I stand there is this video of mine that is going viral and I stand with my words you ask guys whether you have passport or you don't have we need to be arrested we need to go and fix our country so that maybe one day South Africans will come and visit until when guys look at our country we have 65 minerals are being mined in Zimbabwe according to Zimbabwe mining but we don't have our own currents we don't have guys guys until fighting for our rights in South Africa. We need to go and fix our country and I believe the time is now.
Let's sayuru then we give my brother game.
No, let's chrome. Sorry. Sorry. Let's say Chrome.
Chrome. Let's chrome.
Related Videos
US-Iran War LIVE: US Launches New Strikes On Iranian Military Site Near Bandar Abbas | WION Live
WION
6K views•2026-05-28
Guess Which Country Trump Is Threatening To Bomb Next! w/ Chris Hedges
thejimmydoreshow
5K views•2026-05-30
TRUMP LIVE | POTUS makes massive announcement on Iran nuke deal in high-stakes cabinet meeting
TheEconomicTimes
536 views•2026-05-28
The Silence Around Alex Coughlan | #80
RealEddieHobbs
2K views•2026-05-28
Did China Get to Marco Rubio?
ChinaUnscripted
1K views•2026-05-28
Sonko Is Now Speaker. But Who Are the Two Men Who Made His Return Possible?
djbwakali
11K views•2026-05-28
Why Was There No Mention of Israel or Gaza in The DNC's Autopsy Report
wearefindout
227 views•2026-05-29
Trump Just Got HUMILIATED... And It's Going VIRAL
harryjsisson
46K views•2026-05-29











