Effective public policy requires accessible, comprehensive data to enable informed decision-making; when government institutions fail to collect or provide essential statistics (such as GP registrations by non-UK citizens, costs of healthcare for undocumented individuals, and translation services usage), it creates an institutional failure that undermines democratic accountability and prevents evidence-based governance.
Deep Dive
Prerequisite Knowledge
- No data available.
Where to go next
- No data available.
Deep Dive
BBC Tried To Trap Rupert Lowe | Rupert Lowe EXPOSES Journalist Over Missing Data in ParliamentAdded:
You don't have illegal migrants living next to you, Emily, because you live in a part of the country that probably doesn't have them.
>> And if you did, you you so you are part of this liberal elite who basically says it's say as do as I say, not as I do.
>> And it only gets sharper from here.
>> So number of GP registrations by nonUK citizens, no data, >> guys. He went to parliament looking for the numbers, but the answer he received could completely change the way you view this debate. In just a moment, you'll hear exactly what happened. are economic migrants, most of them.
>> And that wasn't even the moment that broke the conversation wide open. The part where the journalist simply couldn't answer. That moment is still coming. Before we roll this from the top, if you think this kind of exchange belongs on mainstream television, share this video right now. Not a like, a share. That's what helps push this beyond the algorithm.
>> Will feel more comfortable speaking in their native language. Right. The >> I have no interest in that. Well, fine.
Like >> they should speak English. They live in England. They should speak English.
>> Doctors take an oath. The first thing is that when it comes to things like translations that that's so patients can access healthcare. It's the job of the NHS.
>> They can't speak English. Ash, they should.
>> Wait, wait, wait. Did I interrupt you, Robert? Did I interrupt you? No, I >> didn't. I'm sorry. We don't need >> No, no, no, wait. Let me finish. All right. The NHS exists to provide the best possible care to patients. Now, some of those patients will feel more comfortable speaking in their native language. Right. The >> I have no interest in that. Well, fine.
Like >> they should speak English. They live in England. They should speak English.
>> Doctors take an oath to give whatever patient comes to their door the best possible quality of care. That is going to involve some translation services.
When it comes to things like DEI, I'm sorry. You are picking the things which play to your base. That's your job as a politician. That is your job as a politician.
That is not that is not where the problem is. The problem is is that we've had 14 years of austerity. The country has become less healthy, measurably less healthy. It's become poorer. The Michael Marmet report laid this out. The most deprived regions are also the most unhealthy. They are the most impacted by austerity.
>> Well, you're certainly right on that.
I've got a question. I think for the permanent secretary, I mean, do you agree with me that that good data is the basis on which good decisions are made rather than bad decisions? That that's how I've always run my businesses. I mean, do do you do you agree that's a logical uh uh summary of of how people make good decisions rather than bad decisions?
>> It is entirely how we would hope to do so. Yes.
>> Okay. Well, well, I I've asked a lot of questions through my parliamentary office. So, number of GP registrations by nonUK citizens, no data. Number of illegal accessing health care services, no data. Cost of treating those with no right to be here, no data. Nationality and immigration status of NHS users, no data. Patient category F breakdown between illegals and visitors, no data.
cost, monetary and time of translation, interpretation across the NHS, no data.
On questions about standards of English and the health service, >> this argument does have a point worth hearing. 14 years of austerity did genuinely damage public health and the Marmmont reports that that part is grounded in evidence. But here's the issue. Rupert Low is asking a very direct question. How do you fix a system when you are not even properly measuring it? No data. And that is not just a political complaint. It points to an institutional failure. Keep watching.
>> I've asked what steps you're taking to ensure overseas recruits can speak English effectively. I haven't had an answer.
>> And do you do you think we've had too much illegal and legal migration? You probably don't.
>> And let the midgetes.
>> Do you do you think we've had too much legal and illegal immigration in the recent past?
>> This is not about me. This is >> You're not answering the question. You are expecting me to answer the question.
You're not answering them. I I I said what I said because I mean it.
>> And at the end of the day, if you don't think the British people agree with me, then you're wrong. because they do.
They've had enough of it. You don't have illegal migrants living next to you, Emily, because you live in a part of the country that probably doesn't have them.
>> And if you did, you would want them to you. So, you are part of this liberal elite who basically says it's say as do as I say, not as I do. Okay? So, uh I'm sorry. What what I meant was and I mean it is if our legal system doesn't allow us to detain and deport, we should set up a tented camp uh on an island. We should not treat them unfairly, but we should equally not put them at the top of uh waiting lists for dental treatment, for medical treatment. We should not give them spending money. We should not effectively treat them as if they have been taxpayers for years. They haven't been. They are illegal migrants.
And by the way, they're not asylum seekers. They're economic migrants. Most of them. So I I I mean I know the virtue signaling dogooders want to sort of feel good about themselves, but if you really want to go go and live next to these people, go and you go and spend your life and you have them ogling at your children in school and things. No, that's wrong. And what's happened is our state no longer puts the honest, decent, taxpaying British citizen at the top of the agenda. They have been relegated to a secondass citizen. And we are bringing people in here who've contributed nothing, who have come here in here illegally, and most of them have been allowed to stay for the simple reason that we're signed up to all these nonsensical international treaties that are meaningless. And as as and why do you think people voted to leave the European Union? Why do you think they did? Because they want their country back. They want their borders back. They want sanity back. So I'm sorry. Yes. If they want to come here, come here. And if you can't deport them, put them on an island until they ask to go home >> and let them >> And who else who else does that?
Australia do that, don't they? Have you heard of Nairu Island in Australia? Do Australians does Australia now have a problem with illegal immigration? No, it used to. Doesn't now. So, I'm afraid sometimes you have to be hard to be kind. And these people will learn very quickly, don't come to the UK. It is not just going to hand out a load of candy to you and let you take priority over the people who've lived here all their lives. British people don't want that.
>> And do you do you think we've had too much illegal and legal migration?
>> You probably don't.
>> And let the midgetes do.
>> Do you do you think we've had too much legal and illegal immigration in the recent past?
>> This is not about me. This is >> You're not answering the question. You are expecting me to answer the question.
You're not answering them.
>> Well, one day I'll come on your show, Robert, and we can do a good interview then.
>> You can come on my podcast.
>> That would be lovely. Thank you very much.
>> Pleasure. We're going to keep going. I urge people do not allow this recidivist agenda of of of saying we are going to split the vote. We're not. We're bringing people back to vote, people who haven't voted for many years because they've become disaffected uh with what's been delivered by all the parties concerned by this Westminster establishment that has lost sight of reality and I think is now serving itself, not the people.
So, if you if you support what we're doing, do not allow uh the siren voices to uh distract you. Let's carry on. The polling we're getting in in Makerfield is unbelievable. The result we had in Great Yarmouth was almost unprecedented in political history. We're going to keep going. We're going to effectively give an authentic, honest voice to those people who want real change in Britain.
The mainstream media moved on from this exchange within 24 hours. We didn't.
Here's the question for the pinned comment. Was Roert Low right to raise where the journalist lives or did that go too far? Drop your view below. The best response will be pinned. Like, subscribe and share this
Related Videos
US-Iran War LIVE: US Launches New Strikes On Iranian Military Site Near Bandar Abbas | WION Live
WION
6K views•2026-05-28
Guess Which Country Trump Is Threatening To Bomb Next! w/ Chris Hedges
thejimmydoreshow
5K views•2026-05-30
TRUMP LIVE | POTUS makes massive announcement on Iran nuke deal in high-stakes cabinet meeting
TheEconomicTimes
536 views•2026-05-28
The Silence Around Alex Coughlan | #80
RealEddieHobbs
2K views•2026-05-28
Did China Get to Marco Rubio?
ChinaUnscripted
1K views•2026-05-28
Sonko Is Now Speaker. But Who Are the Two Men Who Made His Return Possible?
djbwakali
11K views•2026-05-28
Why Was There No Mention of Israel or Gaza in The DNC's Autopsy Report
wearefindout
227 views•2026-05-29
Trump Just Got HUMILIATED... And It's Going VIRAL
harryjsisson
46K views•2026-05-29











